СУДЕБНЫЙ  ПРОЦЕСС  –  ИСТОЧНИК  ПРАВА   И  СПРАВЕДЛИВОСТИ

Alexandr Sergeevich  Alexandrov; Irina Alexandrovna  Alexandrova

doi:10.33184/pravgos-2022.1.1

Authors

Alexandr Sergeevich Alexandrov Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6349-9991
Irina Alexandrovna Alexandrova Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.33184/pravgos-2022.1.1

Keywords:

law, criminal procedure, Nizhny Novgorod school of processualists, philosophy of law, theory of state and law, judicial reform, rule-of-law state

Abstract

Abstract. The main purpose of the article is to establish that legal proceedings are not a mere law enforcement, but the creation of law and justice. In addition, it is proved that the modern theory of state and law has turned into scholasticism and has lost its methodological significance. Instead, the theory of criminal procedure created by Nizhny Novgorod scientists claims this role in jurisprudence. The method by which the set goals are achieved is rhetorical argumentation. Results: using the example of the Nizhny Novgorod doctrine of criminal procedure, the article shows how, by going against the canons of dogmatic law, it is possible to create a fundamentally new, integral scientific concept. The article presents three main components of this concept: the doctrine of «law-process», which explains the procedural way of existence of real law – a means of regulation, which includes the postulate of procedural determinism of everything legal; the doctrine of prosecutorial institutions (criminal action) and evidence as two means of establishing law and justice; scientific project of judicial reform, including reorganization of preliminary investigation, renunciation of investigative authority to charge and prove, establishment of a digital adversarial process and transition to the rule-of-law state.

Author Biographies

Alexandr Sergeevich Alexandrov , Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia

Doctor of Sciences (Law), Professor of the Department of Criminal Procedure, Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia

Irina Alexandrovna Alexandrova , Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia

Doctor of Sciences (Law), Associate Professor of the Department of Criminal and Penal Enforcement Law, Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia

References

Постклассическая онтология права : монография / А.С. Александров и др. ; под общ. ред. И.Л. Честнова. – Санкт-Петербург : Алетейя, 2016. – 688 с.

Аверинцев С.С. Византия и Русь: два типа духовности. Статья вторая. Закон и милость / С.С. Аверинцев // Новый мир. – 1988. – № 9. – С. 227–236.

Елистратов А.И. I. Понятие о публичном субъективном праве. II. «Теория субъективных публичных прав» А.А. Рождественского / А.И. Ели¬стратов. – Москва : печ. А.И. Снегиревой, 1913. – 17 с.

Стовба А.В. Правовая ситуация как исток бытия права / А.В. Стовба. – Харьков, 2006. – 75 с.

Павлов В.И. Проблемы теории государства и права : учебное пособие / В.И. Павлов. – Минск : Академия МВД, 2017. – 214 с.

Пантыкина М.И. Право-структура и право-процесс как формы бытия права / М.И. Пантыкина // Философия права. – 2008. – № 5. – С. 36–40.

Честнов И.Л. Право с позиций социокультурной антропологии // Социокультурная антропология права : монография / под ред. Н.А. Исаева, И.Л. Честнова. – Санкт-Петербург : Алеф-Пресс, 2015. – С. 199–277.

Поляков А.В. Общая теория права : учебник / А.В. Поляков, Е.В. Тимошина. – Санкт-Петербург : Изд-во Санкт-Петербургского гос. ун-та, 2005. – 472 с.

Александров А.С. Введение в судебную лингвистику / А.С. Александров. – Нижний Новгород : Нижегородская правовая академия, 2003. – 420 с.

Рождественский Ю.В. Теория риторики / Ю.В. Рождественский. – Москва : Добросвет, 1997. – 597 с.

Доктринальная модель уголовно-процессуального доказательственного права РФ и комментарии к ней / А.С. Александров и др. – Москва : Юрлитинформ, 2015. – 304 с.