№4 (30) 2012 - Юридический журнал Правовое государство: теория и практика

ISSN 2500-0217 / Включен в Перечень ВАК


№4 (30) 2012

№4 (30) 2012

  • Сущность правового государства
  • Проблемы законодательства о коррупции
  • Ораторская речь - как ее построить
  • Иностранцы о правовом государстве


Правовое государство и современный мир


The ideas of the rule-of-law state actualise on the planet


Rayanov F.M. The essence of the rule-of-law state: historical and civilisational approach

Sokolov A.N. Investigation of theoretical and conceptual aspects of the rule-of-law state: scientific approach only

Galiev F.Kh. The notions of the” rule-of-law state” and civil “society” in the socio-cultural dimension


Professor M.M. Utyashev’s reply

Zinurov R.N. Anti-corruption legislation – issues and lacunas

Baisheva Z.V. The composition of the orator’s speech

Andreyeva K.E. Peculiarities of human rights and freedoms respect in Israel

Sidorova E.A. Anti-Americanism phenomenon in Russia

Ivleva T.V., Bayeva R.R., Lobanova Yu.V. The constitutional right of a child to inviolability and the problems of its realisation


Farkhutdinov D.F. To the issue of administrative liability for ecological delinquencies

Vereschagina D.V. On the notion of state and municipal necessity as the grounds to land plot confiscation


Iskhakov E.R. Legislative activities during the reign of Alexander I (1801-1825) in the sphere of healthcare


Minakov P.A., Safronov K.Yu. Conversation with foreign citizens about the rule-of-law state

Balashenko S.A., Vankovich Ye.E. State registration in the sphere of renewable energy: experience of the Republic of Belarus


Ruzanova V.D. Problems of elemental composition of the civil law legislative system

Panov M.V. Principles of arbitration procedure in the practice of arbitration courts

Bumazhnikova O.V. Object as a feature of encumbrance distinguishing it from restrictions in the private law of the Russian Federation

Maltsev A.A. To the issue of legal nature of economic entities participants

Stelmah V.Yu. Subscriber as participant of acquiring information about connections between subscribers and (or) subscriber device

Muratova A.R. Place of the representation institution in the system of civil law



F.M. Rayanov


The article investigates the sources of essential elements of the rule-of-law state formation. Contributions of the early modern age philosophers (J. Locke, D. Hume and E. Kant) to the theory of rule-of-law state formation are revealed. The necessity of adjusting the state and society correlation with the help of such institutions as “civil society” and “rule-of-law state” is given grounds.

Key words: sources of the rule-of-law state, civil society and rule-of-law state, rule-of-law state and the modern world, rule-of-law state in Russia.

1. Hegel, work over the years. In two volumes. V.1. Moscow, 1972.

2. Zhalinsky A. Reriht, Introduction to German law. Moscow, 2001.

3. Kant I. Collected Works. In six volumes. New York: 1965. V.4. Part 2.

4. "Komsomolskaya Pravda" dated July 27, 2012.

5. Morozova LA Theory of State and Law: A Textbook. M., 2007.

6. On the way to identify the essence of the rule of law / / Rule of Law: Theory and Practice. 2012. Number 2.

7. AN Sokolov Rule of law in Russia: status, problems and prospects / / Rule of Law: Theory and Practice. 2011. Number 2.

8. Theory of Law and State: Textbook /. Ed. VV Lazarev. Moscow, 2002.

9. Fukuyama F. strong state. M., 2006.


Legal culture as one of the constituent elements of general public culture on the one hand reflects specifics of the legal consciousness formed by this stage in political   and legal development of the state. On the other hand legal culture is a kind of foundation contributing to the further positive dynamics of social consciousness in this direction. The paper contains the results of the public opinion polls performed by the author.

Key words: legal culture, law-governed state, civil society, social consciousness, legal consciousness.

A.N. Sokolov


The article is devoted to the analysis of errors occurring during the research of the rule-of-law state.

Key words: rule-of-law state, material and formal rule-of-law state, legal law, research errors, civil society.

1. AN Sokolov Fundamental reform of the legal system of Russia - the imperative of time and national security / / International scientific conference "Features of the theory and practice of legal regulation of social relations and enforcement of various legal families of the world through the prism of their experience in the management of the Russian legal system, including including the Ministry of Interior of Russia, May 13, 2011. Kaliningrad KlYuI Russian Interior Ministry.

2. AN Sokolov Rule of law in Russia: status, problems and prospects / / Rule of Law: Theory and Practice. 2011 № 2.

3. AN Sokolov Legal state: from the idea to its materialization: Monograph. - Kaliningrad. Amber Tale, 2002.

4. Utyashev MM The highest form of state - legal / / Rule of Law: Theory and Practice. 2012. Number 2.

5. Mohl, von, Robert. Das Staatsrecht des Koenigsrechts Wuertemberg. Bd.1. Tuebengen, 1829.

6. Stern Klaus. Das staatsrecht der Bundesrepublik Deutschland. B.I. Verlag C.H. Bek, Muenchen, 1977.

7. Welcker Carl Fh. Die letzten Gruende von Recht, Staat und Strafe, 1813. I. Buch., Kap. 6.

8. Aretin, von Yoh. Christ. Staatsrecht der konstitutionallen Monarchie. Bd.1, Altenburg, 1824.

9. Kant I. Collected Works. In six volumes. M., Thought, 1963 - 1966. T. 6 vol.4 part 2.

10. Mayer O. Kerwaltungsrecht. 1895. I.

11. Stein, voh, L. Handbuch der Verwaktungslehre. 3 Aufl.1887. Bd.1.S. 133

12. Thoma R. Rechtsstaatsidee undVerwaltungwissenschaftyor Bd.4 (1910).

13. Ellwein T. Das Erbe der Monarchie in der deutschen Staatskrise. Muenchen, 1954.

F.Kh. Galiev


Legal culture as one of the constituent elements of general public culture on the one hand reflects specifics of the legal consciousness formed by this stage in political and legal development of the state. On the other hand legal culture is a kind of foundation contributing to the further positive dynamics of social consciousness in this direction. The paper contains the results of the public opinion polls performed by the author.

Key words: legal culture, rule-of-law state state, civil society, social consciousness, legal consciousness.

1. Galiev FH Legal culture and public opinion / FH Galiev S.A.Lartseva, RR Yapparova. - Ufa DizaynPoligrafServis, 2011.

2. Civil society: the origins and modernity / Science editor prof. II Radically. - St.: Publishing House "Press Law Center," 2000.

3. Problems of the theory of state and law: a textbook / Ed. V.M.Syryh. - New York: Penguin Books, 2008.

4. Message from the President of the Russian Federation Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation / / Rossiyskaya Gazeta. 2003. May 17.

5. Rayanov FM The theory of law: challenges of modernization. - Ufa of Sciences of Belarus, Guillem, 2010. 6. Marchenko MN State and Law in the context of globalization. - M.: Prospect, 2009.

7 Stepanov YS Constants. Dictionary of Russian culture. Research experience. - Moscow School "Languages ​​of Russian Culture", 1997.

8. Farkhutdinov IZ, Galiev FH The role of law in the Eurasian space / Interview with FM Rayanovym, Doctor of Law, Professor, Director of the Ufa Research Institute for the rule of law, the chief editor of "Rule of Law: Theory and Practice" / / Eurasian Law Journal. 2012. Number 7.

R.N. Zinurov


The article reviews those sides of combating corruption which are not generally accepted to be spoken about. These phenomena of the Russian realties are generally unchallenged and taken for granted as legitimate notions. We speak about “the hidden protectionism”, a situation when a newly appointed to a senior position official employs the reliable and loyal subordinates and even friends and acquaintances from his old post. The author investigates this phenomenon from legal, ethical and moral points of view, speculate on the admissibility of the latter, moral and psychological climate in the collective, speaks his position and gives recommendations.

Key words: corruption, customs border, deputy, official.

1. VI Popov. Crime that threatens national security. Moscow, 2010.

2. A.L.Karabanov, S.K.Melkin. Modern problems of anti-corruption. Criminal and criminological aspects. Moscow, 2010.

3. Maksimov SV Corruption Crime in Russia: legal assessment, development sources, control measures / / Problems of corruption. Moscow, 1999.

Z.V. Baisheva


The article is devoted to the issues of public speech composition: the most valuable conceptions of the composition, existing in the Russian science, are viewed. Special attention is paid to different compositional schemes of topic narration.

Key words: speech composition, systemic and logical narration (linear, parallel, mixed type), retrospective narration (induction, deduction, traduction, discreet formation, methods of narration (contrastive, problem, step, concentric)

1. VV Vinogradov About prose. Moscow, Leningrad, 1930, VV Vinogradov On the language of literature. Moscow, 1959 VV Vinogradov Style. Theory of poetic speech. Poetics. Moscow, 1963 VV Vinogradov On the theory of literary language. Moscow, 1971 VV Vinogradov Problems of Russian style. Moscow, 1981; Solganik GY The style of the text. Moscow, 1997; Uspensky B. Poetics composition. Moscow, 1970 Uspensky B. Poetics composition. The structure of the artistic text and typology of compositional forms / / Semantics art. Moscow: Languages ​​of Russian Culture, 1995.
2. Zelenetsky KP Private rhetoric. Odessa, 1849.
3. LG Qaeda The style of the text: the theory of composition - to decode. M. Flint, 2004.
4. Marcus Tullius. Three treatises on oratory. Moscow, 1972 Aristotle. Rhetoric. Poetics. M. Maze, 2000, Marcus Fabius Quintilian. Twelve books of rhetorical instruction. SPb., 1834.
5. VV Odintsov The structure of public speech. Moscow, 1976.
6. VV Odintsov The style of the text. Moscow: Nauka, 1980.
7. VV Odintsov What methods have lecture propaganda? M., 1984.
8. Plato. Op. in 3t. Moscow, 1970. V.2.
9. Russian language. Encyclopedia. Chap. Ed. FP Owl. M.: "Soviet encyclopedia", 1979.
10. S. Rusakov Architectonics and composition of literary and artistic works (scientific-methodological sketch). Tomsk, 1926 Reizov B. The concept of forms of art / / Star. 1953. № 7; Popov Questions latest poetic composition studies / / Problems of Russian literature. Lions, 1966. No. 3. Uspensky B. Poetics composition. The structure of the artistic text and typology of compositional forms. Moscow, 1970 Questions of the plot and songs: Intercollegiate Sat No. 4. Bitter, 1980; E. Dobbin story and reality. Art detail. L. 1981, Genre, and the composition of a literary work: Intercollegiate Sat Petrozavozdsk 1981, and composition of plot: Intercollegiate Sat scientific papers. T.239. Kuibyshev, 1980, V. Shklovsky energy of delusion. The book is about the story. M., 1981, etc
11. Horses AF Tips lecturers / / About oratory. M. Politizdat, 1973.

K.E. Andreyeva


The article views a topical issue concerning the legal system of Israel – respect of human rights and freedoms. The author researches the influence of lack of written constitution in Israel on the issue of respecting human rights and freedoms. The author discloses the notion “rights and freedoms”.

Key words: citizen’s “rights and freedoms”, the problem of respecting human rights and freedoms, legal system.

1.Deklaratsiya Independence of the State of Israel / / http://www.jewishagency.org/JewishAgency/Russian/Education/Jewish+Life/Festivals/Independence+Day

2. Maryasis D. The formation and development of civil society in Israel. Modern Israel, M., 2001.

3. Human rights and domestic politics of Israel / / http://www.easttime.ru/analitic/2/5/325.html

4. Elon M. Jewish law. SPb., 2002.

E.A. Sidorova.


Anti-Americanism phenomenon in Russia is analysed in the article. Reasons of anti-American rhetoric are singled out and stages of its formation are viewed. The nature of anti-American sentiment is determined. The author gives recommendation how to overcome the anti-Americanism in Russia.

Key words: Anti-Americanism, «the Russian idea»«the American Dream», political tool.

1. Weekly opinion polls "Omnibus polls»: http://wciom.ru/index.php?id=459&uid=111941

2. Maslov A. Stages of growth of anti-Americanism in post-Soviet Russia / / Russian-bound, 18 August 2009: http://www.pereplet.ru/text/maslov01aug09.html

3. Levada Center poll "Russians' attitudes to other countries»: http://www.levada.ru/14-06-2012/otnoshenie-rossiyan-k-drugim-stranam

4. Statistics from the editors Gazety.Ru hostility / / BBC, 13.03.2012: http://www.gazeta.ru/comments/2012/03/13_e_4089809.shtml

5. Pechatnov VO "Love bitterness" to America / / International Processes, Volume 4, № 1 (10), January-April 2006.: Http://www.intertrends.ru/tenth/003.htm

6. Utkin AI After the American hegemony / / km.ru, June 10, 2009: http://www.km.ru/news/posle_amerikanskoj_gegemonii

7. Cohen A., Dale H. Russian anti-Americanism: a priority target for US public diplomacy / / Backgrounder, № 2373, Feb. 24, 2010:

8. Shlapentokh V. The puzzle of Russian anti-Americanism: from 'below' or from 'above' / / Europe-Asia Studies, 63:5, pp. 875-889.

T.V. Ivleva., R.R. Bayeva., Yu.V. Lobanova


In the article the authors analyse a child abuse as an aspect of infringement of his constitutional rights. The term, definition, characters, kinds and forms of child abuse are considered. Special attention is given to the concept of child abuse. Also authors give their own definition of the term “child abuse on the basis of the existing notions and definitions.

Key words: child, children, constitutional law, abuse, violence.

1. Bryntseva D. Sirota Ocean / / Rossiyskaya Gazeta № 4874 of 25 March 2009.

2. Olga Vlasova On the question of formalizing the definition of violence in the family. / / "Hope" Collection of articles UNN students FSS / / http://www.unn.ru/rus/f14/k2/students/hopes.htm

3. Oleg Zykov Abuse of a child - the cause of street children, drug abuse and crime / / juvenile justice, 2006 № 4.

4. Zimin L. The right to happiness - each child. / / Ufa. 2010. № 6.

5. Zinoviev N., Mikhailova N.F.Psihologiya and psychotherapy violence. Child in Crisis situation. - M.:. Speech, 2003.

6. Kolpakov LA Domestic violence: victimological aspect differentiation of responsibility

and matters of legislative technique / LA Kolpakov. The Dissertation for the degree of k.yu.n Yaroslavl 2007.

7. The Constitution of the Russian Federation of December 12, 1993. / / Publishing Group Infra - M - Norma. Moscow, 1997.

8. Lebedeva's parents-in-law / / Rossiyskaya Gazeta. 2008. № 4612. March 14.

9. Morozov, M., A. Victims Minchenkova invisible front / / Novye Izvestia. 2010. March 17.

10. Safonov T.YA specialized care center for children suffering from abuse Treatment Children of Russia: Violence and Protection, M. 1997.

11. Safonov TJ, Tsymbal E. Child abuse and its consequences / Ill child abuse: the nature, causes, social and legal protection. Moscow, 1993.

12. Children's rights in Russia in a European perspective / / Participation in the preparatory meeting

Russian NGOs to the EU delegation at the consultations Russia - EU Human Rights. April 16, 2008., Ljubljana, Slovenia / / http://www.pravorebenka.narod.ru.

13. Press service of the Presidential Commissioner for Children's Rights Pavel Astakhov / /


14. M. Ulyanov Beats - so relative. / / Rossiyskaya Gazeta № 173 of 10 August 2007.

15. Evgeny Tsymbal Child abuse: causes, symptoms, consequences. M., 2007.

16. Shahi VI Domestic violence: the criminal law and criminological value / V. Shahs dissertation for the degree of Ph.D. Kazan: 2003.

17. Sharov torture for stepson. / / Rossiyskaya Gazeta. 2007. № 132. June 22.

D.F. Farkhutdinov


The article reviews the problems of administrative liability for ecological delinqeuncies perfection.

Key words: environment, administrative and ecological delinquencies, administrative liability for ecological delinquencies perfection, corpus delicti of ecological delinquency.

1. Abramov VG The concept of environmental offenses in the present stage of development sociology and law / / Bulletin of Mordovia State University. 2009. Number 4.

2. Dubovik O. Environmental law: questions and answers. M:. Prospect, 2001.

3. Ivakin VI The concept and structure of environmental offenses / / Law and the State: teoriyai practice. 2007. Number 11.

4. Code of Administrative Offences of 30 December 2001. № 195-FZ.

5. Smirnova Administrative responsibility for environmental offenses. / / Science and Practice. 2010. № 2 (16).

6. Federal Law of 10 January 2002. № 7-FZ "On Environmental Protection", Article 75-80.

D.V. Vereschagina


The article includes analysis of legal regulation, theoretical views and judicial practice on the issue of such notions as state and municipal necessity as the reason for land plot confiscation. Proportion of public and private principles of land plot confiscation were investigated, criteria of appropriation some cases to the reasons for land plot confiscation are revealed. The recommendations which can be used in law-making process are given.

Key words: state and municipal necessities, reasons for land plot confiscation, borders of state intrusion in a private field, social necessity, social usefulness, stability of a civil turn.

1. Arakelyan RG Reservation and withdrawal of land plots in the mechanism of legal regulation of property relations: the Civil Aspects: Abstract: ... Candidate. jurid. Science. - Krasnodar, 2007.

2. Bezbakh VV Private ownership of land in Latin America (legal regulation). - M.: Mirror, TEIS. 1997.

3. A. Venediktov State socialist property. Publishing House of the Academy of Sciences. - Moscow, Leningrad, 1948.

4. Evstigneev VA Ownership of land in the focus of interest / / World of Law. 2004. Number 8.

5. Land Code - Code of Laws of the Russian Federation, 2001, № 44, st.4147 (in red. Federal Law of 25.06.2012 № 93-FZ).

6. Ilyukhin IS Protection of the rights of citizens in seizure of land for public needs: Diss. ... Candidate. jurid. Science. - Moscow, 2011.

7. Kabytov NP Land acquisition as the basis for terminating the right of private property: Diss. ... Candidate. jurid. Science. - Samara, 2004.

8. Kabytov NP Grounds for withdrawal of land for public use / / Appeal. Arbitrations. 2008. Number 3.

9. Kleimenova ES Legal regulation of withdrawal (redemption) of land for public needs: Diss. ... Candidate. jurid. Science. - Eagle, 2008.

10. Mattei, U., EA Sukhanov The main provisions of the law of property. M. Yurist, 1999.

11. SI burns Russian dictionary: approx. 53,000 words. Moscow: LLC "Publishing ONYX", "Publisher" Peace and Education ", 2010.

12. Determination of the Russian Federation of 08.07.2010 № VAS-9062/10 the case number A57-15367/2009 / / Legal reference system "Consultant Plus" [electronic resource] / Company "Consultant Plus".

13. Peskov AA Balance public and private interests in the exercise of the right to judicial protection of municipal property / / Constitutional and municipal law. - Moscow: Jurist, 2010, № 10.

14. Resolution of the Federal Volga District of 15.06.2009 in case number A65-19967/2008 / / Legal reference system "Consultant Plus" [electronic resource] / Company "Consultant Plus".

15. Minutes № 1 to the European Convention on Human Rights / Code of Laws of the Russian Federation. 2001, № 2, st.163.

16. Sklovsky KI Ownership in civil law. - 4th ed., Rev., Ext. - Moscow: The Statute, 2008.

17. Tuzhilova Ordanskaya-EM Problems of protection of property rights in civil law in Russia. Moscow: «Publishing House" Bukvoved ", 2007.

18. Shershenevich GF Textbook of Russian civil law. M. Spark, 2005.

E.R. Iskhakov


The article  analyses Russian legislation of the period from 1801 to 1825 (period of the tsar Alexander the First) on heakthcare.

Key words: legislation on public healthcare, history of medicine

1. Samokvasov DY The course of history russkago law. Third edition, revised and expanded. Moscow Printing Imperatorskago Moskovskago University. 1908).

2. CCL RI. First meeting. T. 27. № 20110.

3. CCL RI. First meeting. T.28. № 20406.

4. Police in Russia. Documents and Materials (1718-1917 gg.). Saratov 2002.

5. A. Moiseev Medical Board of the Ministry of Interior. St. Petersburg. 1913.

6. History of the Ministry of Interior. Part 1, 1858. Varadinov N. SP-B, in the printing MIA

7.Istoriya Moscow military hospital in connection with the history of medicine in Russia for the 200th anniversary of its 1707-1907 gg composed AN Alelekovym. M. Printing Moskovskago Staff Military District 1907.

S.ABalashenko., Ye.EVankovich


The questions related to the registration of renewable energy sources in the Republic of Belarus are analysed in this article. The authors note that the main way of the governmental registration is conducting the state cadastre of renewable energy sources, which is committed by the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environmental Protection of the Republic of Belarus. The procedure for registration of renewable energy sources and the correlation between registration and monitoring of renewable energy sources are also analyzed in the article.

Key words: renewable energy resources, energy legislation of the Republic of Belarus, registration of renewable energy sources.

1. Instruction on Certain Aspects of the state cadastre of renewable energy sources: approved. Ordinance of the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environmental Protection of Belarus, on 29 August 2011., № 29 / / IS "Consultant: Belarus' [electronic resource]. - Minsk, 2012.

2. Instructions on the procedures and conditions for equipment users and manufacturers of electricity meters for its consumption: approved. Ordinance of the Ministry of Energy, December 14, 2011. № 69 / / IS "Consultant: Belarus' [electronic resource]. - Minsk, 2012.

3. Kolotinskaya, EN Legal Basis Natural Resources of inventories in the USSR / EN Kolotinskaya. - Moscow: Mosk. University Press, 1986.

4. Frost, L. Organizational and legal aspects of the formation of inventories and inventory control relations / L. Frost / / State and law. - 1999. - № 4.

5. On Renewable Energy Law of the Republic of Belarus, on 27 December 2010., № 204-N / / IS "Consultant: Belarus' [electronic resource]. - Minsk, 2012.

6. On the use of renewable energy sources: the Law of the Republic of Tajikistan, January 12, 2010., № 587 / / IS "Legislation of the CIS countries" [electronic resource]. - Moscow, 2012.

7. On Energy Conservation Law of the Republic of Belarus, on 15 July 1998., № 190-N / / IS "Consultant: Belarus' [electronic resource]. - Minsk, 2012.

8. Burns, SI Dictionary of Russian: Approx. 100,000 words, terms, and idiomatic expressions / SI Ozhegov. - Moscow: LLC "Publishing Onyx", 2010.

9. Regulation on the procedure of the state cadastre of renewable energy and the use of its data: approved. Resolution of the Council of Ministers, June 24, 2011., № 836 / / IS "Consultant: Belarus' [electronic resource]. - Minsk, 2012.

10. Rules of the state cadastre of renewable energy sources: approved. Government of the Republic of Tajikistan, 03 March 2011., № 116 / / IS "Legislation of the CIS countries" [electronic resource]. - Moscow, 2012

V.D. Ruzanova


The article is devoted to the problematic issues in the application of the concept “an element of a system”, which has been developed in the general theory of systems, to the characterisation of normative legal act as an element of a civil legislative system. In this case the very concept of an “element” thoroughly researched and an attempt to “adapt” it to the legal matter is made.

Keywords: system, element of a system, normative legal act, act of a branch of law, integrated act, civil legislation, civil legislative system.

1. Averyanov AN Category of "system" in dialectical materialism. - M.: Thought, 1974.

2. V. Afanasiev Consistency and society. - M. Politizdat, 1980.

3. Ahlibininsky BV, Asse VA ShorohovI.M. The principle of determinism in system studies. - Leningrad: Publishing House of Leningrad State University, 1984.

4. Averyanov AN Systematic knowledge of the world: a methodology. problems. - M. Politizdat, 1985.

5. Blauberg IV, EG Yudin Formation and nature of the systems approach. - Moscow: Nauka, 1973.

6. DA Kerimov Methodology right (subject, function, problems in the philosophy of law). 2nd ed. - Moscow:Avanta +, 2001.

7. Kuzmin VP The principle of consistency in the theory and methodology of Marx. 2nd ed. - M. Politizdat, 1980.

8. Polenina SV Theoretical problems of Soviet legislation. - Moscow: Publishing House "Nauka", 1979.

9. Systematization of economic legislation / Ed. SN Editor Brother. - Moscow: Legal Literature, 1971.

10. VN Sadovsky Foundations of General teoriisistem. Logical and methodological analysis. - Moscow: "Nauka", 1974.

11. Swiderski VI, RA Zobov New philosophical aspects of the elementary structural relationships. LA: LSU, 1970.

12. Makarov MG The complexity and variety of categories of dialectics. - Leningrad: Publishing House "Science."Leningrad Branch, 1988.

13. A. Mickiewicz Acts of Supreme Soviet state. - M., 1967.

14. A. Mickiewicz System of law and legal system: the development of scientific ideas and legislation / / Problems of the modern civil rights: Collection of articles / dia. Ed. V.N.Litovkin, V.A.Rahmilovich. - M. Gorodets, 2000.

15. Tyukhtin VS Reflection, Systems, Cybernetics. - Moscow: "Nauka", 1972.

16. Tyukhtin VS On the approaches to the construction of a general theory of systems / / System analysis and scientific knowledge. Moscow: "Nauka", 1978.

17. Urmantsev YA Beginning of the general systems theory / / System analysis and scientific knowledge. - Moscow: "Nauka", 1978.

18. Shebanov AF Legal system as a scientific basis for the codification / / Soviet State and Law. 1971. Number 12.

M.V. Panov


The article analyses the principles of arbitration procedure of disputes settlement. The analysis is conducted on the basis of Federal Law of the RF №102-FZ dated 24.07.2002 “On arbitration courts in the Russian Federation”, work practice of four permanently acting arbitration courts. The specifics of legal principle realisation of arbitration procedure are described, a comparison of principles of arbitration procedure with other procedure branches of law is given.

Key words: arbitration procedure, principles of arbitration procedure, permanently acting arbitration court, arbitration court record-keeping practice.

1. Afonin MV The role of arbitration in civil rights / / Actual problems of civil law and procedure. Collection of the international scientific-practical conference (dedicated to the memory and the 70th anniversary of the birth of prof. Farhtdinova YF). No. 2. Kazan, 2006.

2. Bagylly TA Principles as the basis of the arbitration procedural activities arbitration / / Arbitration. 2008. Number 5.

3. Bagylly TA Ordinance. Op. Kurochkin SA The concept and principles of the system of arbitration proceedings / / Arbitration and civil procedure. 2005. Number 11. Tagiyev AS The law as a principle mechanism of legal regulation of the economy / / Citizen and Law. 2001. Number 9.

4. SI burns Russian Dictionary. M., 1973.

5. According to the results of the statistical study of the court, we should speak about the total number of about 85% of all cases before this court.

6. Starlings O. On the principle of confidentiality as arbitration / / Arbitration and civil procedure. 2004. Number 10.

7. Rules of Arbitration "Gazprom". M., 200

8. Morozov, ME Legal sources of arbitration / / Arbitration. 2005. Number 3.

9. Federal Law "On arbitration courts"

10. Encyclopedia of Philosophy in 5 vols. / Ed. FV Konstantinov M., 1967. V.4.

11. Legal Dictionary / Ed. AN Azriliyana M., 2007.

12. Legal Encyclopedia / Ed. Tikhomirov M.Yu. M., 1993.

O.V. Bumazhnikova


The article reveals a problem of encumbrance of property being both on the property right, and on other right of the third parties. The author represents the comparative analysis of two concepts – "encumbrance" and "restriction". The conclusion that one of distinctive features of the specified concepts is the object of their influence that the thing is subject to encumbrance, and to restriction – the right is drawn. Thus the author notes that the property, not only being on the property right, but also on other right of the third parties is subject to encumbrance.

Keywords: encumbrance, property encumbrance, right restriction, a ratio of encumbrances with restrictions of the rights, the rights of the third parties.

1. Akkuratov IY, Korshunov, NM, Horev AA On the constraints and burdens of ownership / / State and law. 2000. Number 10.

2. Alekseev VA Property: State registration and Legal Issues. M., 2007.

3. Bezbakh VV Private ownership of land in Latin America (legal regulation). Moscow, 1997.

4. Ierafilov I. The legal nature of property rights to accommodations / / Economy and pravo.1999. Number 2.

5. Kamyshanskii VP Ownership: The limits and restrictions. M., 2000.

6. Kurdinovsky VI Restrictions on the right of ownership of immovable property under the law. Odessa. 1904.

7. Commentaries to the Federal Law "On state registration of rights to real estate and transactions with it" / Under obsch.red. PV Krasheninnikov. Moscow, 1999.

8. Savelyev AA The limitations and burdens of ownership / / Laws of Russia: experience and practice. September 2007. Number 9.

9. Sklovsky KI Ownership in civil law. M., 2000.

10. Federal Law of 21.07.1997g. № 122-FZ "On state registration of rights to real estate and transactions with it" / / NW. 1997. Number 30. st.3594.

11. Federal Law of 16 July 1998. № 102-FZ "On Mortgage (mortgage)" / / NW. 1998. Number 29. St.3400.

12. Federal Law of 21 December 2001. № 178-FZ "On Privatization of State and Municipal Property" / / NW. 2002. Number 4. st.251.

A.A. Maltsev


In the article the author analyses, by referring to the legal-binding and proprietary conceptions, the legal the possibilities of legal nature determination of rights that members of economic societies have towards the legal entities

Key words: economic societies, rights of economic societies’ members, corporate relations, corporation.

1. Appakova TA Protection of the rights of participants companies (problems of theory, legislative regulation, enforcement): Author. dis. Candidate. jurid. Science - St. Petersburg, 2011.

2. Belov VA The problem of civil forms of corporate relations / / Bulletin of the Supreme Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation. 2009. Number 9.

3. Belov VA, Pestereva EV Business entities. Moscow: JSC "TsentrYurInfoR", 2002.

4. Bogatyrev FO On the existence of obligations to intangible interest / / World of Law. 2004. Number 1.

5. Bogatyrev FO The composition of the relative moral civil relations / / World of Law. 2002 № 11. Pp. 84 - 94.

6. Civil Law: Textbook. Part I / Ed. AP Sergeeva, JK Tolstoy. M.: Prospect, 1997. S. 461.

7. Civil law. Ouch-a, 4 T. I. 3rd ed., Rev. and add. - New York: 2008.

8. Gureev VA The problem of protecting the rights and interests of shareholders in the Russian Federation. Moscow: Wolters Kluwer, 2007.

9. Eremeeva TA Economic and moral rights of the shareholders / / Actual problems of civil law: Collected papers. No. 9 / Ed. O. Pintail. Moscow: Norma, 2005. S. 104.

10. Cavelin KD The rights and obligations of assets and liabilities (in ed., 1879) / / KD Cavelin Selected works on civil law. Moscow, 2003.

11. A. Kaminka Joint-stock companies: Legal research. SPb., 1902. T 1.

12. Kirsanov K. The nature of corporate relations / / EJ-Lawyer. 2005. Number 20.

13. Kozlova NV Concept and essence of the legal entity. Essay on the history and theory. Textbook / Sci. Ed.: EM VS - Moscow: The Statute, 2003.

14. The concept of the legislation of the Russian Federation / / Bulletin of the Supreme Arbitration Court of the Russian Federation. 2009. Number 11.

15. Corporate relations in commercial organizations as part of the subject of civil rights: Author. dis. Candidate. jurid. Science. - M., 1999.

16. Kyrov AA Comment to the Federal Law "On Joint Stock Companies". MM: TC "Welby", Publishing House "Prospect", 2005.

17. Lomakin DV Joint relationship. M. Spark, 1997.

18. Pakhomov NN Fundamentals of the theory of corporate relations (legal aspects): Monograph. ECX.: Taxation and Finance. 2004.

19. Pisemsky PA Joint stock company from the point of view of civil law. M., 1876.

20. Chefs YS On the nature and species diversity of shareholder rights / / Civil Law. 2009. Number1.

21. Legal regulation of the companies (Company law): Manual. manual / Ed. EP Gubin. M.: Mirror, 1998. (Authors - VY Bashkinskas, DI Santa, SA Karelin).

22. Prokhorenko V. Liabilities arising out of participation in education of the legal entity (participatory liability) / / Problems of the theory of civil law. No. 2 / Institute of Private Law. M. Statute, 2006.

23. Serdyuk EB Joint stock companies and shareholders: corporate relations and liability. Moscow ID "Jurisprudence", 2005.

24. Laws of the Russian Federation. 1996. Number 1. Art. 1.

25. Laws of the Russian Federation. 1998. Number 7. Art. 785.

26. Tarasov IT The doctrine of joint-stock companies. M., 2000.

27. Tarikanov DV Legal personality of economic entities in civil law in Russia: Author. dis. Ph.D. ECX., 2003.

28. Shevchenko G. The equity securities of: concept, issue, circulation. M. Statute. 2006.

V.Yu. Stelmah


The paper analyses the procedural issues related to the definition of the procedural status of the subscriber in the production of such investigative actions as obtaining information about the connections between users and (or) the subscriber units. The author believes that in giving individual subscriber procedural status participant in the criminal proceedings is not necessary.

Key words: obtaining information about the connections between users and (or) subscriber units, members of the investigative action, the procedural status of the subscriber.

1. Bulatov BB Procedural status of persons in respect of which the indictment activity. Author. diss. ... Candidate. jurid. Science. Omsk, 2011.

2. Dmitriev, AD, SV Zhiganov The delivery of information about the user to the phone IMEI-code in the OSA / / Criminal procedure. 2011. Number 12.

3. Ivanov AN Not all of the information about the subscriber identified by IMEI, make secret phone calls / / Criminal procedure. 2011. Number 12.

4. Comment to the Federal law "On communication": Line item / LK Tereshchenko. - Proizv. Scient. ed. M. Yustitsinform, 2005.

5. Petrov D. Concept and types of contracts for the provision of communications services / / Legal communication. 2008. Number 1.

6. Ryzhakov AP Getting information about the connections between users and (or) the subscriber units. New investigative action / AP Ryzhakov. - M.: Business and Services, 2011.

7. Yuri Sokolov Using information about the connections between users and (or) subscriber units during the preliminary investigation of crimes / / Russian investigator. 2011. Number 11.

A.R. Muratova


This article is devoted to the representation institution, its place in the system of the civil law. On the basis of existing scientific classification of legal institutions, the author reveals specifics of the civil law institution of representation, defines its place in the system of civil law.

Keywords: institution, civil law, representation.
1. Alekseev SS The structure of Soviet law. - Moscow: Legal Literature, 1975.

2. Durneva PN Voluntary representation in civil law in Russia: Dis. ... Candidate. jurid. Science. Krasnodar, 2007.

3. Kirimova EA Law Institute (theoretical and legal research): Dis. ... Candidate. jurid. Science. Saratov, 1998.

4. Laptev, VV, VP Shakhmatov Purpose of legal regulation and the legal system / / Jurisprudence, 1976. Number 4.

5. Pyanov NA Consultations on the theory of state and law. Theme: "The system of law" / / Legal Russia: Federal legal portal v.2.3. St. Petersburg, 2000. URL: http://www.law.edu.ru/doc/document.asp?docID=1138728 (date accessed: 08/05/2012).

6. Sinyukov VN Functions of law / / Theory of State and Law. Course of lectures. Saratov, 1995.


ISSN 2500-0217 / Включен в Перечень ВАК