№ 3 (25) 2011 - Юридический журнал Правовое государство: теория и практика

ISSN 2500-0217 / Включен в Перечень ВАК

 

№ 3 (25) 2011

№ 3 (25) 2011
Inside

  • Ways of formation of the rule of law
  • Analysis of the "Russian project"
  • Civil service
  • Humanitarian Intervention and Contemporary International Law

Feature

Modernization of the state and legal system

COLUMN OF THE EDITOR-IN-CHIEF

ARTICLES
Sokolov A.N.

Ways of rule-of-law state formation in Russia
Ilyshev I.G.
Humanitarian intervention and the present-day international law
Gaiduk V.V.
On the issue of the strong state
Loukmanov Kh. Kh., Ilikaev A.S.
Values of “the Project Russia”: the political-legal analysis
Valeev Kh.A. 
Transformation of the state civil service in the context of the administrative reform in post-soviet federative Russia
Baisheva Z.V.
Toposes in the court speech
Minnigulova D. B.
The legal regulation of collective disputes within the state civil service

OFFICIAL MATERIALS
The Russian President: on the rule of law state
The International Association of Turkic world lawyers

RESEARCH PAPERS
Kayumova R.S.
Problems of the legal consciousness cultivation in the modern youth
Yerkeev I. Kh.
On some problems of ensuring security of the Russian Federation
Shamsutdinov R.K.
Legal status and problems of criminal justice, carried by a single judge
Kurbanov D.A., Khismatullin O.Yu.
The issues of the federal law of 30.04.10 № 68-fz “on compensa-tion for the violation of the right to legal proceedings carried out in reasonable term or right to en-forcement of the judial act in reasonable term” realization
Gazizova L.M.
Some peculiarities of the establishment and development of the Russian federalism

OBITUARY

INFORMATION ABOUT AUTHORS

TO THE AUTHORS

Articles
Sokolov A.N.
Ways of rule-of-law state formation in Russia

Problems, tendencies and prospects of rule-of-law state development in Russia are analysed in the article.
Key words: Law-governed state, civil sociality and it’s criterion, national security strategy, principles of a law-governed state, legal system, police state, legal culture.
Work bibliographic list

1.Sokolov A.N. Pravovoe gosudarstvo v Rossii: problemy i perspektivy razvitija // Pravovoe gosudarstvo: teorija i praktika. 2011. #2.
2.Strategija nacional'noj bezopasnosti Rossijskoj Federacii do 2020 goda. Utverzhdena Ukazom Prezidenta RF ot 12 maja 2009 g. #537.
3.Juridicheskaja praktika kak kriterij jeffektivnosti upravlenija obshhestvom: monografija / pod red. A.N. Sokolova, V.M. Bocharova. Kaliningrad: KlJuI MVD Rossii, 2008. S. 38; v 2004 godu v Rossii bylo 48 partij, segodnja – sem' / Rossijskaja gazeta 2010, 28 janvarja. S. 2.
4.Poroshkina Ju.O. Pravovoj separatizm regionov kak ugroza nacional'noj bezopasnosti Rossijskoj Federacii. Avtoreferat diss… na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni kand. jur. nauk. M., Akademija gossluzhby pri Prezidente RF, 2000.
5.Poslanie Prezidenta RF Federal'nomu Sobraniju RF «O polozhenii v strane i napravlenijah vnutrennej i vneshnej politiki gosudarstva». Stenogramma vystuplenija. M., 2002. S. 17.
6.Vysheslavcev B. P. Jetika preobrazovanija Jerosa. M., 1994. S. 22.
7.Baranov V.M. Koncepcija zakonoproekta. Uchebnoe posobie. N.-Novgorod, Nizhegorodskaja akademija MVD Rossii, 2003; Kuznecov S.V. Informacionnye tehnologii v zakonodatel'noj dejatel'nosti. // Zakonodatel'naja tehnika. M., 2000; Tihomirov Ju.A. Zakonodatel'naja tehnika: ponjatie i jelementy. // Zakonodatel'naja tehnika. M., 2000.
8.Luchin V.O. Konstitucija Rossijskoj Federacii. Problemy realizacii. M., JuNITI-DANA, 2002. S.84.
9.Petrovskaja A.V. Sushhnost' idei pravovogo zakona. Glava 2. V kn.: Sokolov A.N., Petrovskaja A.V. Pravovoj zakon – «sterzhen'» pravovogo gosudarstva. monografija. Kaliningrad: KlJuI MVD Rossii, 2008.
10.Sauljak O.P. Pravovoj nigilizm kak invariant otechestvennogo pravosoznanija //Pravovoe gosudarstvo. 2009. # 9. S. 2
11. Aristotel'. Politika. Kn. VI. gl. IX, par. 8, 9, 10, 11. Shershenevich G.F. Istorija filosofii prava. SPb.: Universitet MVD Rossii, 2001. S. 104.


Articles
Ilyshev I.G.
Humanitarian intervention and the present-day international law

In this article the notion of “Humanitarian Intervention” is critically looked upon. International law does not regulate issues related to internal competence of states. However, the non-interference principle does not presuppose the states’ absolute right to arbitrarily classify all issues as lying within its exclusive domain. On the other hand, an increasing number of issues, voluntarily submitted by states to the international scrutiny, do not mean to disrupt the states’ sovereignty over these issues. Hence, it is virtually impossible to harmonise modern international law with the concept of “humanitarian or benevolent intervention”.
Key words: humanitarian intervention, state sovereignty, domestic jurisdiction of states, international legal standing, jus cogens norms. 
Work bibliographic list

1. Anaya J.S. Indigenous Peoples in International Law. New York, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1996.- p.39.
2. Brownlie I., Principles of Public International Law [Principy mezhdunarodnogo prava], 4-th ed. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1990: 88–91, gde podrobno obsuzhdajutsja razlichnye teorii priznanija gosudarstva.
3. Anaya J. S., Op. cit.: 40.
4. Talbott S., «When Monsters Stay Home», Time, Vol. 137, No. 15, April 15, 1991: 30.
5. Rodley N., «The Work of Non-Governmental Organizations in the World Wide Promotion and Protection of Human Rights», United Nations Bulletin of Human Rights, No. 90/1 (1991): 90–93.
6. Claude R., Burns W. (eds.), Human Rights in the World Community: Issues and Action. 2-d ed. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1992; Van Dyke V., Human Rights, Ethnicity, and Discrimination. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1985.
7. Church G., «The Course of Conscience», Time, Vol. 137, No. 15, April 15, 1991: 28–30.
8. Taylor Ph., Nonstate Actors in International Politics: From Transregional to Substate Organizations. Boulder, Colo.: Westview Press, 1984.
9. Bowett D., The Law of International Institutions. 4-th ed. London: Stevens, 1982.
10. V celom vse soglasny s tem, chto na segodnja imeetsja ochen' neznachitel'nyj svod pravil, vytekajushhih iz obychnogo mezhdunarodnogo prava, kotorye mogli by garantirovat' sobljudenie prav cheloveka i javljalis' by objazatel'nymi dlja vseh gosudarstv, sm.: Janis M., An Introduction to International Law. 2-d ed. Boston: Little, Brown, 1993: 247–49; Farer T., «The United Nations and Human Rights: More Than a Whimper, Less Than a Roar», Human Rights Quarterly 9, 1987: 550-586.
11. Claude R., Burns W. (eds.), Human Rights in the World Community: Issues and Action. 2-d ed. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1992: 3–5; Janis M., An Introduction to International Law. 2-d ed. Boston: Little, Brown, 1993: 227–272; Daes E.I., Status of the Individual and Contemporary International Law: Promotion, Protection, and Restoration of Human Rights at the National, Regional, and International Levels, UN Sales No. E. 91. HIV. 3, 1992: 21.
12. Crawford J. (ed.), The Rights of Peoples, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1988, gde rassmatrivajutsja razlichnye vzgljady na gruppovye prava, sushhestvujushhie v ramkah mezhdunarodnogo prava.
13. V. Inozemcev «Gumanitarnye intervencii: Ponjatie, zadachi, metody osushhestvlenija», «Kosmopolis» (2005. # 1(11)).
14. Simptomatichnym javljaetsja v jetom smysle vyskazyvanie zamestitelja Gosudarstvennogo sekretarja SShA v Administracii B. Klintona Stroba Talbota: «Esli by Adol'f Gitler stroil svoj rejh (so vsemi gazovymi kamerami i koncentracionnymi lagerjami) lish' v predelah byvshej Vejmarskoj respubliki, interesno, poschitalo by mirovoe soobshhestvo fakty massovyh narushenij prav cheloveka i narodov vnutrennim delom Germanii?», Talbott S., “When Monsters Stay Home”, Time, vol. 137, #. 15, April 15, 1991, p.30.
15. Holzgrefe J., Keohane R. (eds.) Humanitarian Intervention: Ethical, Legal and Political Dilemmas. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003. - r.110.


Articles
Gaiduk V.V.
On the issue of the strong state

Today it is high time a consistent conception of the strong state is formed. Thereupon in this article the necessity of its creation is grounded, factors stipulating the need in the powerful, effective and competent state are revealed, its primary and essential attributes are exposed.
Key words: state, strong and powerful state, civil society, power, competent state.
Work bibliographic list

1. Makarov V.L. Gosudarstvennyj audit i proektirovanie budushhego. Vmesto predislovija. V kn.: Stepashin S.V. Gosudarstvennyj audit i jekonomika budushhego. M.: Nauka, 2008. S. 7.
2. Fukujama F. Sil'noe gosudarstvo. Upravlenie i mirovoj porjadok v XXI veke: (per. s angl.). M.: AST: AST MOSKVA: HRANITEL'', 2006. S. 5.
3. Aforizmy: Po inostrannym istochnikam. Sost. P.P. Petrov, Ja.V. Berlin. Predisl. N.M. Gribachjova. 3-e izd. pererab., dop. M.: Progress, 1985. S. 20.
4. Antologija mudrosti. Sost. V.Ju. Shojher. M.: Veche, 2007. S. 415.
5. Putin V.V. Vystuplenie pri predstavlenii ezhegodnogo Poslanija Prezidenta Rossijskoj Federacii Federal'nomu Sobraniju Rossijskoj Federacii. 8 ijulja 2000 goda. Oficial'nyj tekst. M., 2000. S. 9.
6. Poslanie Prezidenta RF Federal'nomu Sobraniju. 5 nojabrja 2008 goda. Moskva, Bol'shoj Kremljovskij dvorec. Rossijskaja gazeta. www.rg.ru. 6 nojabrja 2008 g. # 43 (indeks 32185). # 230 (4787). S. 3.
7. Zatonskij V.A. Jeffektivnaja gosudarstvennost'. Pod red. A.V. Mal'ko. M.: Jurist", 2006. S. 95.
8. Zatonskij V.A. Jeffektivnaja gosudarstvennost'. Pod red. A.V. Mal'ko. M.: Jurist", 2006. S. 91.
9. Ozhegov S.I., Shvedova N.Ju. Tolkovyj slovar' russkogo jazyka: 80000 slov i frazeologicheskih vyrazhenij. 4-e izd., dopolnennoe. M.: Azbukovnik, 1999. S. 716; Tolkovyj slovar' russkogo jazyka. Pod redakciej prof. D.N. Ushakova. V 4-h tomah. Tom IV. M.: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel'stvo inostrannyh i nacional'nyh slovarej. 1940. S. 175; Dal' V.I. Illjustrirovannyj tolkovyj slovar' russkogo jazyka. M.: Jeksmo, 2008. S. 740.
10. Rassel B. Vlast'. Social'nyj analiz. Cit. po: Halipov V.F. Jenciklopedija vlasti. M.: Akademicheskij proekt; Kul'tura, 2005. S. 922.
11. Zatonskij V.A. Jeffektivnaja gosudarstvennost'. Pod red. A.V. Mal'ko. M.: Jurist", 2006. S. 108.
12. Mal'cev G.V. Social'nye osnovanija prava. M.: Norma, 2007. S. 496.
13. Fukujama F. Sil'noe gosudarstvo. Upravlenie i mirovoj porjadok v XXI veke: (per. s angl.). M.: AST: AST MOSKVA: HRANITEL'', 2006. S. 21.
14. Panarin A.S. Rossija v ciklah mirovoj istorii. M.: Izd-vo MGU, 1999. S. 29.
15. Zatonskij V.A. Jeffektivnaja gosudarstvennost'. Pod red. A.V. Mal'ko. M.: Jurist", 2006. S. 89.
16. Panarin A.S. Rossija v ciklah mirovoj istorii. M.: Izd-vo MGU, 1999. S. 52.
17. Panarin A.S. Rossija v ciklah mirovoj istorii. M.: Izd-vo MGU, 1999. S. 51 –52.
18. Dobren'kov V.I., Kravchenko A.I. Sociologija: V 3 t. T. 2: Social'naja struktura i stratifikacija. M.: INFRA-M, 2000. S. 312.
19. Novaja filosofskaja jenciklopedija: V 4 t. T. III. In-t filosofii RAN, Nac. obshh.-nauch. fond. M.: Mysl', 2001. S. 612.
20. Hamaher M. Velikoe protivostojanie. Literaturnaja gazeta. 13-19 fevralja 2008 g. # 6 (6158). S. 3.
21. Fukujama F. Sil'noe gosudarstvo. Upravlenie i mirovoj porjadok v XXI veke: (per. s angl.). M.: AST: AST MOSKVA: HRANITEL'', 2006. S. 6, 8.
22. Panarin A.S. Rossija v ciklah mirovoj istorii. M.: Izd-vo MGU, 1999. S. 284.
23. Mal'cev G.V. Social'nye osnovanija prava. M.: Norma, 2007. S. 511.
24. Marchenko M.N. Gosudarstvo i pravo v uslovijah globalizacii. M.: Prospekt, 2008.S.30–31.
25. Filosofskaja jenciklopedija. Gl. red. F.V. Konstantinov. M.: Sovetskaja Jenciklopedija, 1970. T. 5. S. 119.
26. Kazin A. Ne rasprodat' ni kresty, ni zvjozdy. Kakaja vlast' nuzhna sovremennoj Rossii. Literaturnaja gazeta. 7 – 13 maja 2008 g. # 19 (6171). S. 4.
27. Aforizmy: Po inostrannym istochnikam. Sost. P.P.Petrov, Ja.V. Berlin. Predisl. N.M. Gribachjova. 3-e izd. pererab., dop. M.: Progress, 1985. S. 115.
28. Stiglic Dzh.Ju. Revushhie devjanostye. Semena Razvala. M.: Sovremennaja jekonomika i pravo 2005. S. 23.
29. Dobren'kov V.I. Globalizacija i Rossija: Sociologicheskij analiz. M.: INFRA-M, 2006. S. 8–24;
30. Marchenko M.N. Gosudarstvo i pravo v uslovijah globalizacii. M.: Prospekt, 2008. S. 12 – 13.
31. Globalistika: Jenciklopedija. Gl. red. I.I. Mazur, A.N. Chumakov; Centr nauchnyh i prikladnyh programm «Dialog». M.: OAO Izdatel'stvo «Raduga», 2003. S. 181, 183, 185.
32. Panarin A.S. Rossija v ciklah mirovoj istorii. M.: Izd-vo MGU, 1999. S. 283.
33. Fukujama F. Sil'noe gosudarstvo. Upravlenie i mirovoj porjadok v XXI veke: (per. s angl.). M.: AST: AST MOSKVA: HRANITEL'', 2006. S. 199.


Articles
Loukmanov Kh. Kh., Ilikaev A.S.
Values of “the Project Russia”: the political-legal analysis

The main propositions of “The Project Russia” – a series of books that continue to stir public opinion are viewed in the article. The authors of the article set the goal to explore the essence and values of the political doctrine, described in the project. As a result of the analysis, a number of drawbacks of this doctrine were found, among which we can point out the insufficiency and nonchalance of the arguments, negligence of obvious facts. The authors came to the conclusion that the ideological origins of the ‘‘Project’’ are dubious, because they deny the possibility of coexistence of Christian (Orthodox) church with other confessions and secular ideology. The strategy of building the God’s Kingdom on the earth in the ‘‘Project Russia’’ is characterised by political adventurism, religious intolerance, ignoring of the world experience in constructing democracy and the rule-of-law state.
Key words: political values, multicultural society, the God-given power, mixed government, autocracy, materialism, liberal democracy, Protestantism, post-modernism, Islam, theocracy. 
Work bibliographic list

1. Lukmanov H.H., Ilikaev A.S. O suverennoj demokratii: opyt kriticheskogo prochtenija odnoj politiko-pravovoj doktriny // Pravovoe gosudarstvo: teorija i praktika. # 2 (20). 2010. S. 5.
2. Kaftan L. Chto nas zhdet posle vyborov prezidenta v 2012 godu? // Komsomol'skaja pravda. 2010. 10 oktjabrja.
3. Sharp Dzh. Ot diktatury k demokratii. // per. s angl. N. Makarovoj. Komm. Je. Limonov, A. Cvetkov, I. Shamir, I. Jashin. Ekaterinburg: Ul'tra.Kul'tura, 2005. 224 s.
4. Kljuchnik R. Sovremennaja durilka pod nazvaniem – «Proekt Rossija» / http://www.soprotivlenie.su/delo/materialy/sovremennaya_durilka_pod_nasvaniem_proekt_rossia.html – 5.02.11.
5. Kljuchnik R. Lekcii prezidentam po istorii filosofii i religii. – SPb.: Izdatel'stvo «Kontur – M», 2006. S 773.
6. Rajanov F.M. Rekomendovano prezidentam… // Pravovoe gosudarstvo: teorija i praktika. – # 3 (9) 2007. S. 51.
7. Bajtin M.I. Ponjatie pravovogo gosudarstva i problemy ego formirovanija v Rossii. … // Pravovoe gosudarstvo: teorija i praktika. # 3 (9) 2007. S. 12.
8. Proekt Rossija. Vtoraja kniga. Vybor puti. M.: Jeksmo, 2007. S. 24.
9. Proekt Rossija. Tret'ja kniga. Tret'e tysjacheletie. M.: Jeksmo, 2009. S. 37.
10. Utjashev M.M. Politicheskaja i pravovaja doktrina otkrytogo obshhestva // Pravovoe gosudarstvo: teorija i praktika. # 4 (6) 2006. S. 12. S. 8.
11. Shalyganov Ju.V. Proekt Rossija. Bol'shaja ideja. Chetvertaja kniga (2010). http://projectrussia.orthodoxy.ru/ – 8.03.11.
12. Kljuchnik R. Sovremennaja durilka pod nazvaniem – «Proekt Rossija» / http://www.soprotivlenie.su/delo/materialy/sovremennaya_durilka_pod_nasvaniem_proekt_rossia.html – 5.02.11.


Articles
Valeev Kh.A. 
Transformation of the state civil service in the context of the administrative reform in postsoviet federative Russia

Reform of the state civil service is one of the key areas of administrative reform in Russia. At the present stage this institution is only starting to acquire traits of a professional administrative staff machinery.
In the process of the reform the state civil service was formed as a type of state service. At the same time, many problems are still to be solved. State employees are regarded by the society as a caste of officials
The federal program of “Reform and development of state civil service system of the Russian Federation (2009-2013)” is called upon to solve this and many other problems.
Key words: administrative reform, political modernisation, state service, state civil service.
Work bibliographic list

1. Gosudarstvennaja grazhdanskaja sluzhba: uchebnik / V.D. Grazhdan. – 2-e izd., pererab. i dop. – M.: KNORUS, 2007.
2. Krasnov M.A., Obolonskij A.V. Reforma gosudarstvennoj sluzhby Rossii: Istorija popytok reformirovanija s 1992 po 2000 gody. M.: Ves' mir, 2003.
3. Ivanov V.P. Reformirovanie gosudarstvennoj sluzhby: voprosy i perspektivy. // Zhurnal «Rossijskoe pravo», 2003. # 5.
4. Barcic I.N. O konceptual'nyh napravlenijah razvitija sistemy gosudarstvennoj sluzhby Rossijskoj Federacii. // Zhurnal rossijskogo prava, 2008. # 6.


Articles

Baisheva Z.V.
Toposes in the court speech

The article deals with one of the most important elements of the rhetorical argumentation – general points (toposes) in the court speech. The author analyses the main types of toposes used by court speakers. And the role of toposes in making persuasive court speech is shown on the examples of speeches made by famous Russian lawyers of the 19 and the 20th centuries.
Key words: topos, general point.


Articles
Minnigulova D. B.
The legal regulation of collective disputes within the state civil service

The possibility of collective disputes within state civil service into is viewed in the article. The legislation which regulates the state civil service does not prohibit collective service disputes. That is why the possibility of normative legal regulation of the collective disputes within the state civil service is proposed for theoretical discussion.
Key words: state civil service legislation, state civil servants, conflicts in state civil service, prohibitions and restrictions, individual service disputes, conciliatory procedures, the right to strike. 
Work bibliographic list

1. O gosudarstvennoj grazhdanskoj sluzhbe Rossijskoj Federacii: feder. zakon ot 27 ijulja 2004 g. # 79-FZ // Ros. gaz. 2004. 31 ijulja.
2. Trudovoj kodeks Rossijskoj Federacii: feder. zakon ot 30 dekabrja 2001 g. #197-FZ // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federacii. 2002. # 1. St. 3.
3. O sobranijah, mitingah, demonstracijah, shestvijah i piketirovanijah: feder. zakon ot 19 ijunja 2004 g. # 54-FZ // Sobranie zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federacii. 2004. # 25. St. 2485.
4. Ob osnovah gosudarstvennoj sluzhby Rossijskoj Federacii: feder. zakon # 119-FZ ot 31.07.1995 (utratil silu) // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federacii. 1995. # 31. St. 2990.
5. Pravovoe obespechenie gosudarstvennoj sluzhby Rossijskoj Federacii: uchebnik /pod obshh. red. I. N. Barcica. - M.: RAGS, 2007 560 c.
6. Bahrah D. N. Administrativnoe pravo Rossii: ucheb. dlja vuzov 3-e izd., peresmotr. i dop.- M.: NORMA, 2007. 816 s.
7. Ob organizacii predostavlenija gosudarstvennyh i municipal'nyh uslug: feder. zakon # 210-FZ ot 27.07.2010 // Ros. gaz. 2010. 30 ijulja.
8. Konstitucija Rossijskoj Federacii (prinjata vsenarodnym golosovaniem 12.12.1993) // Ros. gaz. 1993. 25 dek.
9. O professional'nyh sojuzah, ih pravah i garantijah dejatel'nosti : feder. zakon # 10-FZ ot 12.01.1996 // Sobr. zakonodatel'stva Ros. Federacii. 1996. # 3. St. 148.
Research papers
Kayumova R.S.
Problems of the legal consciousness cultivation in the modern youth
The legal consciousness is extremely individual. However it should comply with the public consciousness, so the legal theories, ideas, views established in society must be reflected in the legal consciousness of the person. Today the main idea of the public legal consciousness is an idea of the high social value of law, of the necessity for adherence to it, strict adherence to the due process of law. This particular idea should be in the spotlight during the legal education of young people.
Keywords: public legal consciousness, high social value, legal education.
Work bibliographic list
1. Granat N.L. Pravovoe soznanie. M., 1985.
2. Il'ina I.A. Vospitanie pravovogo soznanija. M., 1979.
3. Komarov S.A. Formirovanie pravovogo soznanija. M., 1988.
4. Luk A.N. Jemocii i lichnost'. M., 1982.
5.Harlamov I.F. Pedagogika. M; L., 1990.


Research papers
Yerkeev I. Kh.
On some problems of ensuring security of the Russian federation

The article investigates the most important aspects of ensuring security of the Russian Federation: status, problems, contradictions, tendencies. Factors that had a negative influence on the development of the legislation in the sphere of security are viewed and a general concept of security is formulated.
Keywords: object of security, subject of security, security, national security.
Work bibliographic list

1. Doklad Soveta Federacii Federal'nogo Sobranija Rossijskoj Federacii 2009 goda «O sostojanii zakonodatel'stva v Rossijskoj Federacii» / pod obshh. red. S.M. Mironova, G.Je. Burbulisa. M.: Sovet Federacii, 2010. S.188-189.
2. Kozlova A.V. Politicheskie mehanizmy obespechenija bezopasnosti gosudarstva v jekonomicheskoj sfere Diss. …d-ra polit. nauk. Moskva, 2009. S.20.
3. Kondakov N.I. Logicheskij slovar'-spravochnik. M.: Nauka, 1975. S.88.
4. Ozhegov S.I., Shvedova N.Ju. Tolkovyj slovar' russkogo jazyka. M., 1994. S. 444
5. Migracija i bezopasnost' Rossii / Pod red. G. Vitkovskoj i S. Panarenko. Mosk. Centr Karnegi. M.: Interdialekt+, 2000. S. 17.
6. Dal' V. Tolkovyj slovar': v 4-h tomah. M.: Russkij jazyk, 1989. T. 1. S. 67-68.
7. Deutsch K. Politics and Government. P. 45.
8. Teorija gosudarstva i prava: Uchebnik / Pod red. prof. V.Ja. Kikotja, prof. V.V. Lazareva. 3-e, pererab. i dop. izd-e. M., 2007. S.517.
9. Bobylev A.I. Teoreticheskie problemy razvitija grazhdanskogo obshhestva v Rossijskoj Federacii //Aktual'nye voprosy gosudarstva i grazhdanskogo obshhestva na sovremennom jetape: Materialy mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii 10-11 aprelja 2007 g. Chast' 1. Ufa: RIC BashGU, 2007. S.24-25.
10. Filosofskij jenciklopedicheskij slovar'. M., 1983. S.661.
11.Husainov Z.F. Mehanizm obespechenija jekonomicheskoj bezopasnosti obshhestva i gosudarstva v processe sozdanija osnov rynochnoj jekonomiki v Rossii // Uchenye zapiski Kazanskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Kazan', 2008. Tom 150, kn.5. S.94.


Research papers
Shamsutdinov R.K.
Legal status and problems of criminal justice, carried by a single judge

This article is devoted to the realisation in the Russian legal system of the institution of the criminal case sitting of a single judge. On the analysis of the law provision, court practice, statistics, theses of the criminal procedure studies the major problems of organisation of modern legal proceedings (court workload, court errors, problems of personnel selection of judges, etc.) are presented and the recommendation on tackling these problems and legislation perfection are given.
Key words: court of justice, the sole form of criminal justice, miscarriages of justice, judicial reform.
Work bibliographic list

1. Sovet Evropy i Rossii: Sbornik. M.: Jurid. lit., 2004. S. 508, 685.
2. Bekkarija Ch. O prestuplenijah i nakazanijah. M., 2004. S. 115.
3. Vlasov V. Mirovoj sud kak forma narodnogo samoupravlenija. // Rossijskaja justicija. 1995. #7, s. 21.
4. Egorov V. Sud'i dolzhny izbirat'sja narodom // Rossijskaja justicija. 2004. # 4. S. 11.
5. Ob jetih dannyh sm.: Rossijskaja justicija. 2007 # 8; 2008 # 4; 2009 # 6; 2010 # 9.
6. Dannye Otdela sudebnoj statistiki Sudebnogo departamenta pri verhovnom sude RF.7.
7. Vladimirov D. Specsud dlja chinovnikov //Rossijskaja Gazeta. 2006. 11 marta. S. 2.
8. Rossijskaja justicija. 2007. # 8., 2008 # 4., 2009 # 6., 2010 # 9.
9. Ruzanova N. 60 let svobody / /Rossijskaja Gazeta 2005. 11 fevralja S. 15.
10. Kozlova N, Kulikov V. Tri milliona i izvinenija //Rossijskaja gazeta. 2005. 14 dekabrja. S. 2.
11. Kozlova N., Borisov T. V sude skryvalis' ot suda // Ros. gazeta. 2005. 30 nojabrja. S. 11.
12. Kulikov V. Lebedev grozit bjurokratam kodeksom // Ros. gazeta. 2006. 29 nojabrja. S. 1-2.


Research papers
Kurbanov D.A., Khismatullin O.Yu.
The issues of the federal law of 30.04.10 № 68-fz “on compensation for the violation of the right to legal proceedings carried out in reasonable term or right to enforcement of the judial act in reasonable term” realization

The present article is devoted to the issues of implementation of Federal law №. 68-FZ of April 30, 2010 “On compensation for the violation of the right to legal proceedings in reasonable term or the right for enforcement of the judicial act in reasonable term”. The preconditions of adoption of the right to monetary compensation in case of excessive delay in the fair judicial process as well as some problems arising from the adoption of the mentioned law are analysed. The key issues of the institute of compensation practices are scrutinized and potential problems are identified.
Key words: law, compensation, judicial act, the European Court, the Constitutional Court.


Research papers
Gazizova L.M.
Some peculiarities of the establishment and development of the Russian federalism

Some aspects of establishment and development of the Russian federalism in the soviet era are viewed and some peculiarities of evolution of legal regulation of a constituent entity of the federation are singled out. According to the author’s point of view the capacity of the constituent entity of the federation to carry out its own legal regulation, result of which is represented in the legal system of the constituent entity, is one of the characteristic features of the federative state.
Key words: federation, constituent entity of a federation, constitution, legal system of a constituent entity of a federation.
1. Abdulatipov R.G. Poisk perspektiv rossijskogo federalizma // Federalizm. 2001. #4 (24).
2. Abdulatipov R.G. Federalogija. SPb., 2004. S. 106.
3. Aznagulov V. Optimizacija federativnyh i regional'nyh otnoshenij. Opyt Bashkortostana. Ufa, 2005. S. 15.
4. Arhippov K.A. Sovetskie avtonomnye oblasti i respubliki. M., 1925. S. 160.
5. Borisova M.M. Koncepcija pravovogo statusa sub"ekta Rossijskoj Federacii: Avtoref. dis. … kand. jurid. nauk. Saransk, 2005. S.13.
6. Gradovskij A.D. Nachala russkogo gosudarstvennogo prava. SPb., 1823.
7. Zheleznov B.L. ASSR – vysshaja forma sovetskoj avtonomii. Kazan', 1984. S.68.
8. Zlatopol'skij D.L. SSSR – federativnoe gosudarstvo. M., 1967. S. 80-83.
9. Kim A.I. K voprosu o gosudarstvenno-pravovoj prirode RSFSR // Pravovedenie. 1960.
# 1. S.29-30.
10. Levin I.D. Suverenitet. M., 1948. S. 337.
11. Lepeshkin A.I. Sovetskij federalizm. M., 1970. S. 77-79.
12. Lysenko V. Federalizm ot Tatarstana do Chechni. M., 1998.
13. Mal'cev G.V. Ponimanie prava: podhody i problemy. M., 1999. S. 98.
14. Osnovy teorii i praktiki federalizma. M., 1999.
15. Problemy suvereniteta Rossijskoj Federacii. M., 1994. S. 65.
16. Spiridonov L.I. Teorija gosudarstva i prava. M., 1995. S. 62.
17. SU RSFSR. 1917. # 2. St. 18.
18. Tjeps D. Konceptual'nye osnovy federalizma. SPb.: Izd-vo «Juridicheskij centr Press», 2002. S. 69.
19. Chistjakov O.I. Stanovlenie Rossijskoj Federacii (1917-1922). M., 1966.
20. Chistjakov O.I. Konstitucija RSFSR 1918 goda. Izd. 2-e, pererab. M.: IKD «ZERCALO-M», 2003. S. 199.
21. Shhetinin B.V. Sovetskoe gosudarstvennoe pravo. Kurs lekcij. Vyp. 4. M., 1966. S. 108.
22. Shapsugov D.Ju. Voprosy suvereniteta i gosudarstvenno-pravovaja priroda avtonomnoj respubliki: Avtoref. diss. … kand. jurid. nauk. Rostov-n/D, 1971. S. 12.
23. Jashhenko A.S. Russkij federalizm // Federalizm. 1996. # 1. S.138.
24. Jusubov Je.S. Teorija federalizma v Rossii. Tomsk, 1998. S. 47.

 

ISSN 2500-0217 / Включен в Перечень ВАК