№ 2 (20) 2010 - Юридический журнал Правовое государство: теория и практика

ISSN 2500-0217 / Включен в Перечень ВАК

 

№ 2 (20) 2010

№ 2 (20) 2010
Inside

  • About sovereign democracy: the experience of reading a critical political and legal doctrines
  • Legal culture as a major part of the culture and rights
  • On the relation between the principles and features of the rule of law
  • Generally recognized principles and norms of international law - part of the legal system, law or legislation

Feature

Democratic constitutional state - the only right direction of development of modern Russia

Column of the Editor-in-Chief

State and Law theory
Lukmanov Kh. Kh., Ilikaev A.S.
On the Sovereign Democracy: Critical Perusal of a Political-and-legal doctrine.
Galiev F.Kh.
Legal culture as part and parcel of culture and law.
Yanbukhtin N.R.
The institution of municipal property in land: background.
Fasgiev T.A.
The image of an ideal knyaz in “The Sermon on Law and Grace” by metropolitan Hilarion.
Khazhipov R.Kh.
On correlation of principles and attributes of a rule-of-law state.

Criminal policy of the state
Svirin Yu.A.

Proposition of legislation improvement in sphere of executive law.
Kuchin O.S.
On scientific approaches to the development of the new definition of “illegal turnover of valuables” in criminology.
Galimkhanov A.B.
Legal expertise in the criminal process.

Legislation perfection issues
Kuznecova O.A., Marino I.

Generally recognised principles and norms of the international law: part and parcel of a legal system, law or legislature?
Gabitov M.R.
The problems of legal education and their correlation with legislative practice
Valeev Kh.A.
State civil service in the system of state administration of modern Russia: problems of human resources.
Garipov R.F.
Private ownership of land: the experience of agrarian reforms in Russian and the countries of  Eastern Europe.
Abdrakhmanov A.F.
Legal regulation of the state civil service in the Russian Federation and the Republic of Bashkortostan.
Gidiyatullina I.N.
Evolution of the notion “revenue” in the illegal enterprise.
Bebik N.V.
On the problems of justice of peace apparatus optimisation.
Suyundukova A.Yu.
On the issue of autonomous financial liability of a peasant (farm) enterprise
Meschaninov A.P.
Methodological approaches to the definition of “management” in the administrative law.

To the Authors.

State and Law theory
Lukmanov Kh. Kh., Ilikaev A.S.
On the Sovereign Democracy:  Critical Perusal of a Political-and-legal doctrine

The article deals with the history of the conception of the sovereign democracy, it gives its tentative political and legal analysis. The authors try to find the most adequate definition of the sovereign democracy, citing among other things extracts from the speeches by foreign political leaders. One of the principal conclusions of the article is that the conception under consideration proves to be an ideological reactions to legal nihilism in international relations. Unlike the majority of  political-and-legal doctrines the conception of the sovereign democracy doesn’t claim the role of a strict theory. Its importance is fully confirmed by the fact that as V. Surkov pointed out the necessity exists to remind the political elite of Russia of such most sig-nificant categories as sovereignty and authority by the people.
Key words: sovereignty, democracy, people’s sovereignty, state sovereignty, political regime, legal doctrine, ideological reaction.
Work bibliographic list
1.Medvedev D. Dlja procvetanija vseh nado uchityvat' interesy kazhdogo / Pro suverennuju demokratiju: Sbornik / sost. Poljakov D.V. — M.: 2.Izdatel'stvo «Evropa», 2007. — S. 217. (Dalee — SD).
3.Bochkareva S., Rumjancev F. NII Suverennoj demokratii. // Politika. — 2007. — 10 dekabrja.
4.Pljajs Ja. «Suverennaja demokratija» — novyj koncept partii vlasti. // Vlast'. — 2008. — #4. — S. 24-32.
5.Bilevskaja Je., Samarina A. Suverennuju demokratiju zamenjat sostjazatel'noj. // Nezavisimaja gazeta. — 2009. — 30 sentjabrja.
6.Stanovaja T. Vladislav Surkov prezentoval «suverennuju demokratiju». http://www.politcom.ru/article.php?id=2999 — 03.12.09.
7.Surkov V. Nacionalizacija budushhego. // SD. — S. 394.
8.Suverennaja demokratija. http://dic.academic.ru/dic.nsf/ruwiki/150238 — 26.02.10.
9.Moshkin M. Suverennaja demokratija dlja Bol'shogo prostranstva. Sajt Mezhdunarodnogo evrazijskogo dvizhenija (material ot 10.11.06). http://www.evrazia.info/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=3361 — 10.01.10.
10.Ilikaev A.S. Teoretiko-metodologicheskie osnovy izuchenija organicheskoj demokratii: Preprint. — Ufa: RIO BashGU, 2004. — S. 3.
11.President Prodi's Speech on «Europe and peace» at the University of Ulster. April 1, 2004. European Union & United Nation. http://europa-eu-un.org/articles/fr/article_3372_fr.htm — 12.01.10. Ibid.
12.Medvedev D. Dlja procvetanija vseh nado uchityvat' interesy kazhdogo / SD. - S. 218.
13.Boden Zh. Shest' knig o respublike (gosudarstva) // Antologija mirovoj pravovoj mysli. - M., 1999. - T. 2. - S. 692.
14.Ilikaev A.S. Ukaz. soch. - S. 3.
15.Sokolov M. Suverenitet i svoboda. / SD. - S. 18.
16.Rogozhnikov M. Chto takoe suverennaja demokratija / Ukaz. Ist. - S. 27.
17.Ivanov V. «Demokratija - jeto vam ne lobbio kushat'» / SD. - S. 70-71.
18.Batchikov S. Sodom i Gomorra. / SD. - S. 112.
19.Jur'ev M. Dve logiki v rossijskoj politike. / SD. - S. 157-158.
20.Lukmanov H.H., Mal'ceva L.L. Smertnaja kazn' v pravovom gosudarstve. / Pravovoe gosudarstvo. - # 2 (4) 2006. - S. 18.
21.Radzihovskij L. Edinaja rossijskaja jelita. / SD. - S. 75.
22.Novichkov P.S. Suverennaja demokratija v kontekste globalizacii / Tezisy dokladov. V Vserossijskij kongress politologov «Izmenenija v politike i poli-tika izmenenij: Strategii, instituty, aktory». Moskva, 10-20 nojabrja 2009 g. – M.: Rossijskaja associacija politicheskoj nauki, 2009. - S. 531.
23.Novichkov P.S. Ukaz. soch. - S. 532.
24.Narochnickaja N. Pora li Rossii podelit'sja nedra-mi s Zapadom. / SD. - S. 455.
25.Romancheva I. Surkov rasskazal o plane Putina. http://www.internet-school.ru/Enc.ashx?item=539655 - 03.12.09.
 
 
State and Law theory
Galiev F.Kh.
Legal culture as part and parcel of culture and law

The general state and problems of the development of the legal culture under conditions of formation and development of the rule-of-law state are viewed in the article.
The legal culture as a phenomenon, combining specific features of the general culture and law, is progressing according to the modern tendencies of state and social development. 
Thus the full spectrum of social relations and their state-legal enforcement features are reflected in the article.
Key words: rule-of-law, law, culture, legal culture, legal behaviour, legal consciousness, legal regulation.
Work bibliographic list
1.Parsons T. O strukture social'nogo dejstvija. – Izd. 2-e. – M.: Akademicheskij Proekt, 2002. – S.444.
2.Rajanov F.M. Gosudarstvenno-pravovye «bolezni»: istoricheskij diagnoz. – Ufa: NIIPP (Nauchno-issledovatel'skij institut problem prava), 2005. – S.98-99.
3.Stroev E.S. Samoopredelenie Rossii i global'naja modernizacija». – M.: ZAO «Izdatel'stvo «Jekonomika», 2001. - S.133.
Pravo i kul'tura: monografija /Pod obshh. red. V.K.Egorova, Ju.A.Tihomirova, O.N.Astaf'evoj. – M.: Izd-vo RAGS, 2009. – S.36-37.
4.Obolonskij A.V. Bjurokratija dlja HH1 veka? Modeli gosudarstvennoj sluzhby: Rossija, SShA, Anglija, Avstralija. – M.: Delo, 2002. - S.143.
5.Zaslavskaja T.I. Societal'naja transformacija Rossijskogo obshhestva. Dejatel'nostno-strukturnaja koncepcija. – 2-e izd., ispr. i dop. – M.: Delo, 2003. - S.151.
6.Bagliev M.A. Musul'manskaja sostavljajushhaja sovremennoj civilizacii. V kn.: Mir i Rossija na po-roge HH1 veka: Vtorye Gorchakovskie chtenija. MGIMO MID Rossii (23-24 maja 2000 g.) – M.: «Rossijskaja politicheskaja jenciklopedija» (ROSPJeN), 2001. - S.389.
7.Chehov A.P. Pis'mo bratu Nikolaju Pavlovichu, mart 1886 goda. // Sobranie soch. v 12 tt., t.11. – M.: Hudozhestvennaja literatura, 1956. - S.83-85.
8.Mal'cev G.V. Ponimanie prava. Podhody i problemy. – M.: Prometej, 1999. – S.404-406.
9.Teorija gosudarstva i prava: Uchebnik. Izd. 2-e, pererab., dop. – M.: Jeksmo, 2007. –S.407.
10.Chehov A.P. Pis'mo bratu Nikolaju Pavlovichu, mart 1886 goda. // Sobranie soch. v 12 tt., t.11. – M.: Hudozhectvennaja literatura, 1956. - S.83-85.
11.Mal'cev G.V. Ponimanie prava. Podhody i problemy. – M.: Prometej, 1999. – S.404-406.
12.Teorija gosudarstva i prava: Uchebnik. Izd. 2-e, pererab., dop. – M.: Jeksmo, 2007. –S.407.
 
 
State and Law theory
Yanbukhtin N.R.
The institution of municipal property in land: background

The author investigates different types of local government which predetermine peculiarities of local government legislation. The land legal relations of the foreign and Russian legislations, particularly the institution of Municipal property in land, are analysed.
Key words: institution of municipal law, municipal property in land, local self-government, legislation, land legal relations.
Work bibliographic list
1.Mestnaja vlast' // Sbornik dokumentov i materialov. - Ufa: RIZO BAGSU, 1999. - S.267.
2.Cit. po: Ditjatin N.I. Ustrojstvo i upravlenie gorodov Rossii. T.1. - SPb.; Jaroslavl', 1875-1877. - S.505.
3.Pashkov B.T. Rus', Rossija, Rossijskaja imperija /Hronika pravlenij i sobytij 1862-1917 gg. : Centr Kom., 1997. - S.631.
4.Balezin V.P. Pravovoj rezhim zemel' gorod-skoj zastrojki. - M., 1963. - S. 13.
5.Balezin V.P. Ukaz. soch. S. 14.
6.Balezin V.P. Uka. soch. - S. 30.
 
 
State and Law theory
Fasgiev T.A.
The image of an ideal knyaz in “The Sermon on Law and Grace” by metropolitan Hilarion

The article reveals the  essence of  state-legal views of one of the most recognized authors of the Middle Ages in Russia.  The Hilarion’s doctrine of parity of all peoples, his theory of world history as a gradual and equal communication of all peoples with Christianity is viewed in the article. The image of an “ideal knyaz” is presented in the interpretation of the church hierarch, particularly his merit as a “teacher and mentor of our land”. One of the aspects of the published work is the demonstration of the original nature of thenadays sources of law.
Key words: law, grace, Hilarion, Christianity, baptiser, sacral, enlightener, reformer. 
Work bibliographic list
1.Lihachev D.S. Povest' vremennyh let (istoriko-literaturnyj ocherk) // Povest' vremennyh let. Ch. 1. - S. 309.
2.Moldovan A.M. «Slovo o zakone i blagodati» Ilariona. - Kiev, 1984. - S. 91. (dalee: Slovo).
3.Chirkin V.E. Osnovy gosudarstvennoj vlasti. - M., 1996. - S. 74.
4.Povest' vremennyh let / Pod red. V.P. Andrianovoj-Peretc. Izd. vtoroe, ispravlennoe i dop. - SPb., 1996. Ch. 1. (dalee: PVL). - S. 53.
5.Chichurov I.S. Politicheskaja ideologija srednevekov'ja (Vizantija i Rus'). M., 1991. S. 136.
6.Sverdlov M.B. Vladimir Svjatoslavich Svjatoj – knjaz' i chelovek // Kul'tura slavjan i Rus'. - S. 86.
7.Averincev S.S. Vizantija i Rus': dva tipa duhovnosti // Novyj mir. - 1988. #7. - S. 211.
8.Kuzenkov P.V. Okruzhnoe poslanie // Drevnejshie gosudarstva Vostochnoj Evropy 2000 g.: Problemy istochnikovedenija / Otv. red. L.V. 9.Stoljarova; otv. red. ser. E.A. Mel'nikova. - M., 2003. - S. 69.
10.Drevnjaja Rus' v svete zarubezhnyh istochnikov / Pod red. E.A. Mel'nikovoj. - M., 2003. - S. 104.
11.Chichurov I.S. Ukaz. soch. S. 135.
 
 
State and Law theory
Khazhipov R.Kh.
On correlation of principles and attributes of a rule-of-law state

The article “On correlation of principles and attributes of a rule-of-law state” deals with the problem of revealing of specific features and peculiarities of this type of state.  The emphasis is laid on revealing the nonidentity of the notions “principles” and “attributes”, their definitions and concrete types are given.
Key words: “principles of the rule-of-law state”, “attributes of the rule-of-law state”, “supremacy of law and legal law”
Work bibliographic list
1.Kurs lekcij po teorii gosudarstva i prava / Pod red. N.A. Kataeva i V.V.Lazareva. - Ufa, 1994. – S. 204; Obshhaja teorija prava i gosudarstva / Pod red. V.V.Lazareva. - M., 2003. – S. 422-429; Teorija gosudarstva i prava / Pod red. A.G.Habibullina, V.V.Lazareva. – M., 2009. – S. 235-236; Chervonjuk V.I. Teorija gosudarstva i prava. – M., 2007. – 656-660; Teorija gosudarstva i prava / Pod red. M.M.Rassolova. – M., 2004. – S. 174-178.
2.Lazarev V.V., Lipen' S.V. Teorija gosudarstva i prava. – M., 1998. – S.398-401; Obshhaja teorija gosudarstva i prava. Akademicheskij kurs v 2-h tomah. // Otv. red. M.N.Marchenko. Tom 1. - M., 1998. – S. 373-382; Rajanov F.M. Pravovoe gosudarstvo – sud'ba Rossii. – Ufa, 2007. - S.135-137: Obshhaja teorija prava / Pod obshh. red. A.S.Pigolkina. – M., 1996. – S. 332-334; Nersesjanc V.S. Filosofija prava. – M., 1998. – S. 106- 107 i dr.
3.Teorija gosudarstva i prava / Pod red. N.I.Matuzova i A.V.Mal'ko. - M., 1997. – S.183-189; Teorija gosudarstva i prava / Otv. red. V.D.Perevalov. - M., 2004. – S. 359-363; Kulapov V.L., Mal'ko A.V. Teorija gosudarstva i prava. – M. 2009. – S. 164-172; Juridicheskij jenciklopedicheskij slovar' / Pod obshh. red. V.E.Krutskih. – M., 2001. - S. 311; Syryh V.M. Teorija gosudarstva i prava. – M., 2005. – S. 538-542; Oksamytnyj V.V. Teorija gosudarstva i prava. – M., 2004. – S. 296-297.
4.Sovetskij jenciklopedicheskij slovar' / Glavnyj red. A.M.Prohorov. – M., 1989. – S.1071; Kratkaja filosofskaja jenciklopedija / Red. E.F.Gubskij, G.V.Korableva, V.A.Lutchenko. – M., 1994. – S.362-363.
5.Ozhegov S.I., Shvedova N.Ju. Tolkovyj slovar' russkogo jazyka. – M., 1998. – S.591.
6.Kulapov V.L, Mal'ko A.V. Teorija gosudarstva i prava. – M., 2008. – S. 166.
7.Sokolov A.N. Pravovoe gosudarstvo: ot idei do materializacii. – Kaliningrad, 2002. – S. 11-12.
8.Ljubashic V.Ja., Mordovcev A.Ju., Mamychev A.Ju. Teorija gosudarstva i prava. – M., 2010. – S. 298-299.
9.Kasimov T.S. Ponimanie pravovogo gosudarstva v sovremennoj rossijskoj juridicheskoj nauke // Pravovoe gosudarstvo: teorija i praktika. – 2009. -# 3. – S. 13.
10.Chirkin V.E. Gosudarstvovedenie. – M., 1999. – S. 36-42.
11.Prava cheloveka / Otv. red. E.A.Lukasheva. – M., 2003. – S.178-179.
12.Sokolov A.N. Ukaz. soch. – S.144-190.
 
 
Criminal policy of the state
Svirin Yu.A.
Proposition of legislation improvement in sphere of executive law

The article “On correlation of principles and attributes of a rule-of-law state” deals with the problem of revealing of specific features and peculiarities of this type of state.  The emphasis is laid on revealing the nonidentity of the notions “principles” and “attributes”, their definitions and concrete types are given.
Key words: codification, Civil Procedure Code, legal status of the third party, debtor’s temporary restriction to leave, bailiff’s responsibility, plaintiff’s responsibility.
 
 
Criminal policy of the state
Kuchin O.S.
On scientific approaches to the development of the new definition of “illegal turnover of valuables” in criminology

The author examines issues of the onset and formation of a new definition of “illegal turnover of valuables” in criminology. In the course of his investigation the author analysed the issues of philosophy, philology, civil and criminal law taking into account the specifications of criminology. The given definition is introduced by the author instead of the definition of “illegal turnover of precious metals and gems” as he considers it more broadly defines criminological type of the above-stated crimes.
Key words: illegal turnover of valuables,  valuables of limited transferability, axiology, precious metals, gems, object of civil law rights, defence capacity.
Work bibliographic list
1.Vasilenko I.A. Politicheskij konsensus v gumanitarnom dialoge kul'tur // Voprosy filosofii.-1996.- # 8.-S. 49.
2.Manhejm K. Dialog nashego vremeni. - M.: Jurist, 1994.-S. 429-431.
3.Sossjur F. de. Trudy po jazykoznaniju. – M., 1977. – S. 147-148.
4.Otec Andrej Kuraev. O vere i znanii – bez antimonij//Voprosy filosofii. - 1992.-# 7.-S. 47.
5.Kravec A.S. Smysly i cennosti: ontologija i teorija poznanija.//Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Ser. 7, Filosofija.-2007.-# 6.- S. 3.
6.Zhukov V.N. Vvedenie v juridicheskuju aksiologiju (voprosy metodologii) // Gosudarstvo i pravo, 2009, # 6.-S. 20.
7.Perov Ju.V., Perov V.Ju. Filosofija cennostej i cennostnaja jetika// Gartman N. Jetika. - SPb., 2002.-S. 10.
8.Zhukov V.N. Vvedenie v juridicheskuju aksiologiju (voprosy metodologii) // Gosudarstvo i pravo, 2009. - # 6.-S. 21.
9.Ozhegov S.I. Slovar' russkogo jazyka // Pod red. chlena-korr. AN SSSR N.Ju.Shvedovoj. - M.: «RUSSKIJ JaZYK», 1990. S.871.
10.Sovetskij jenciklopedicheskij slovar' // Pod red. A.M. Prohorova. M.: «SOVETSKAJa JeNCIKLO-PEDIJa», 1984. S. 1462.
11.Kratkij filosofskij slovar' // Otv. red. d.f.n. A.P. Alekseev. - M.: «PROSPEKT», 2008. - S. 435-436.
12.Zhukov V.N. Vvedenie v juridicheskuju aksiologiju (voprosy metodologii) // Gosudarstvo i pravo, 2009. - # 6.-S.26.
13.Mihajlova N.S. Oborotosposobnost' veshhej v grazhdanskom prave i rol' aktov organov vnutrennih del Rossijskoj Federacii v ee realizacii: diss… kand. jurid. nauk: 12.00.03 - SPb. 2007.
14.Mihajlova N.S. Oborotosposobnost' veshhej v grazhdanskom prave i rol' aktov organov vnutrennih del Rossijskoj Federacii v ee realizacii: avtoref. diss… kand. jurid. nauk: 12.00.03. - SPb. 2007. – S. 10-11.
15.Mihajlova N.S. Oborotosposobnost' veshhej v grazhdanskom prave i rol' aktov organov vnutrennih del Rossijskoj Federacii v ee realizacii: avtoreferat diss… kand. jurid. nauk: 12.00.03, SPb, 2007. – S. 5.
16.Gejzenberg V. Fizika i filosofija. Chast' i celoe. – M., 1989. – S. 85.
17.Kohanovskij V.P., Zolotuhina E.V., Leshkevich T.G., Fathi T.B. Filosofija dlja aspirantov: Uchebnoe posobie.- Rostov n/D: «Feniks», 2002. – S. 319.
18.Slovar' sovremennogo russkogo literaturnogo jazy-ka / Pod red. L.S. Kovtun i I.N. Shmelevoj, T.8. L.: Izd-vo AN SSSR, 1959.-S. 335-339.
19.Aleksandrova Z.E. Slovar' sinonimov russkogo jazyka: prakticheskij spravochnik. – M.: Izd. «Russkij jazyk», 1995.- S. 241, 481.
20.Dal' V. Tolkovyj slovar' zhivogo velikorusskogo jazyka. T. 2.- M.: Gos. izd-vo inostr. i nac. slovarej. 1955.-S.611-612.
21.Ozhegov S.I. Slovar' russkogo jazyka. - M.: Gos. izd-vo inostr. i nac. slovarej. 1952.-S.152, 387, 809; Ozhegov S.I. Slovar' russkogo jazyka. - M.: Gos. izd-vo inostr. i nac. slovarej. 1963.- S.173, 421-422; Ozhegov S.I. Slovar' russkogo jazyka.// Pod red. N.Ju. Shvedo-voj. M.: «Russkij jazyk», 1989.- S. 181, 432, 871.
22.Slovar' sovremennogo russkogo literaturnogo jazyka // Pod red. L.S. Kovtun i V.P. Petushkov, T.17, Izd-vo «Nauka», Leningrad, 1965.-S. 630-633;Tolkovyj slovar' russkogo jazyka: s vkljucheniem svedenij o proishozhdenii slov / Otv. red. akademik RAN N.Ju. Shvedova. Izd. centr «Azbukovnik», M., 2007.-S. 214, 543, 1078.
23.Bol'shaja Sovetskaja jenciklopedija / Gl. red. B.A. Vvedenskij, izd. 2-e, T. 30. M.: 1954.- S. 367-371.; Malaja Sovetskaja jenciklopedija / Gl. red. N.L. Meshherjakov, izd. 2-e, T. 7, M., 1937.- S. 607-610.; Bol'shaja Sovetskaja jenciklopedija / Gl. red. A.M. Prohorov, izd. 3-e, T.18, M.: 1974.- S. 211-213.
24.Komissarov V., Popov A. Mezhdunarodnye valjutnye i kreditnye otnoshenija. - M.: Mezhdunarodnye otnoshenija. 1965. S. 305.
25.Filippov A.G. Obshhie polozhenija metodiki rassledovanija otdel'nyh vidov i grupp prestuplenij (kriminalisticheskoj metodiki): Uchebnik. - 2-e izd. - M., 2000.-S. 407.
26.Gauhman L.D., Serova M.V. Otvetstvennost' za mel-koe hishhenie gosudarstvennogo ili obshhestvennogo imushhestva. - M., 1990. – S. 42.
27.Chistova L.E. O sootnoshenii ugolovno-pravovoj i kriminalisticheskih harakteristik // Vestnik kriminalistiki / Otv. red. A.G. Filippov, Vyp.1 (17). - M.: Spark, 2006.-S.38.
 
 
Criminal policy of the state
Galimkhanov A.B.
Legal expertise in the criminal process

Topical and debatable issues of admissibility of carrying out the legal expertise and its possibility of to use the expert’s statement as a proof in a criminal process. The defence tactics at the infliction and procedure of the expertise during prejudicial inquiry are viewed.
Key words: forensic legal expertise, special knowledge, expert’s statement, right to protection, defence tactics.
Work bibliographic list
1.Jani P. «Pravovaja» jekspertiza v ugolovnom dele. // Zakonnost'. – 2001. - #1 // SPS «Konsul'tantPljus»
2.Kudrjavceva A., Livshic Ju. Dokazatel'stvennoe znachenie «pravovyh» jekspertiz v ugolovnom processe // Rossijskaja justicija. – 2003. - # 1 // SPS «Konsul'tantPljus»
3.Halikov A.N. Vozmozhna li pravovaja jekspertiza v ugolovnom sudoproizvodstve //Problemy naznachenija i proizvodstva sudebnyh jekspertiz v processe rassledovanija prestuplenij: Materialy Vserossijskoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii. 15-16 marta 2007 g. - Ufa: UJuI MVD RF, 2007 – S. 122.
4.Ugolovnyj process: uchebnik dlja studentov vuzov / pod red. A.P. Gus'kovoj, A.V. Endol'cevoj. – M.: JuNITI-DANA: Zakon i pravo, 2007. – S.337.
5.Jeksarhopulo A.A. Special'nye poznanija v ugo-lovnom processe i ih netradicionnye formy // Vestnik kriminalistiki. Vyp. 2. - M., 2001. - S. 26.
 
 
Legislation perfection issues
Kuznecova O.A., Marino I.
Generally recognised principles and norms of the international law: part and parcel of a legal system, law or legislature?

Foreign and domestic normative, doctrinal and law-enforcement approaches to the inclusion of the generally recognised principles and norms of the international law in the legislation, law and a legal system of a state are analysed in the article. It is grounded that regardless of constitutional proclamation of the generally recognised principles and norms of the international law as part and parcel of a legislature, law or a legal system, they have to be administered by state bodies as property of a independent and autonomous international legal system in compliance with the requirements and rules of interpretation of the interna-tional law, not the national one.
Key words: Generally recognised principles and norms of the international law, legal system, positive law as part of a legal system, domestic law, legislation.
Work bibliographic list
1.Kadyralieva B.D. Obshhepriznannye principy i normy mezhdunarodnogo prava i mezhdunarodnye dogovory kak chast' pravovoj sistemy Kyrgyzskoj Respubliki // Moskovskij zhurnal mezhdunarodnogo prava. - 2007. - # 2. - S. 172.
2.Pavlova L.V. Implementacija dogovornyh objazatel'stv Respubliki Belarus' v nacional'nom zakonodatel'stve // Moskovskij zhurnal mezhdunarodnogo prava. - 2006. - # 1 - S. 205.
3.Usenko E.G. Sootnoshenie i vzaimodejstvie mezhdunarodnogo i nacional'nogo prava i rossijskaja Konstitucija // Moskovskij zhurnal mezhdunarodnogo prava. - 1995. - # 2. - S. 18.
4.Pshenichnikov M.A. Konstitucii Ros-sii i mezhdunarodnoe pravo: problemy garmonizacii / Pod red. V.M. Baranova. - N. Novgorod: Nizhegorod. pravovaja akademija, 2002. - S. 51.
5.Marochkin S.Ju. Dejstvie norm mezhdunarodnogo prava v pravovoj sisteme Rossijskoj Federacii. - Tjumen': Tjumenskij gos. un-t, 1998. - S. 22.
6.Kanashevskij V.A. Normy mezhdunarodnogo prava i grazhdanskoe zakonodatel'stvo Rossii. - M.: Mezhd. otnosh., 2004. - S. 31.
7.Morozova L.A. Teorija gosudarstva i pravo: uch-k. - M.: Jeksmo, 2009. - S. 284.
8.Raushning D. Primenenie norm mezhdunarodnogo publichnogo prava v ramkah nacional'noj pravovoj sistemy // Rossijskij ezhegodnik mezhdunarodnogo prava. 1998-1999g. - S. 279.
9.Ginzburgs Dzh. Amerikanskaja jurisprudencija o vzaimodejstvii mezhdunarodnogo i vnutrennego prava // Gosudarstvo i pravo. - 1994. - # 11. - S. 152.
10.Sorokin V.V. K ponjatiju pravovoj sistemy // Pravovedenie. - 2003. - # 2. - S. 4.
11.Alekseev S.S. Obshhaja teorija prava: uchebnik. - M.: TK Velbi, Izd-vo prospekt, 2008. - S. 65. On zhe. Pravo: azbuka – teorija – filosofija. Opyt kompleksnogo issledovanija. - M.: Statut, 1999. - S. 47.
12.Matuzov N.I. Aktual'nye problemy teorii prava. - Saratov: Izd-vo Saratovskoj gos. akademii prava, 2004. - S. 94.
13.Vishnevskij A.F. Obshhaja teorija prava: uch. posobie / A.F. Vishnevskij, N.A. Gorbatok, V.A. Kuchinskij. - Mn.: Amalfeja, 2004. - S. 303.
14.Teorija gosudarstva i prava: uchebnik / Otv. red. V.D. Perevalov. - M.: Norma, 2008. - S. 412.
15.Sorokin V.V. Ukaz. soch. - S. 13.
16.Lukashuk I.I. O primenenii mezhdunarodnogo prava sudami Rossii // Gosudarstvo i pravo. - 1994. - # 2. - S. 112.
 
 
Legislation perfection issues
Gabitov M.R.
The problems of legal education and their correlation with legislative practice
This article deals with the problems of legal education. Accordiny to the author these problems arise because there is no system of teachiny of History and Theory of State and Law and theoretical material does not correspond to the law of information theory. The analysis of the legistature especially. Federal law “State Cadare Property ” sows that the legislature has the same short-comings as the theoretical material in judicial Institutions of Higher Education.
Key words: system, theory of information, theoretical definitions, informational programs.
Work bibliographic list
1.Slovar' inostrannyh slov. Pod red. I.V. Lehina, S.M. Lokshinoj, F.N. Petrova i L.S. Shaumjana. M., 1964.
2.Strany mira. Sovremennyj spravochnik/sost. Gorjachkina T.V., Jarich I.G. – M., 2003.; Vse strany mira/Avt.-sost. M.V. Adamchik. – Minsk: Harvest, 2008.
3.Hrestomatija po vseobshhej istorii gosudarstva i prava pod red. Batyra K.I. – M., 2004. T.1. – S.370-374.
4.Levina M.I. Parlamentskoe pravo Velikobritanii XVII-nachala XIX v. – M.,2000. – S.18.
5.Hrestomatija po vseobshhej istorii gosudarstva i prava pod red. K.I.Batyra. – M., 2000. T. 1. S. 89-128.
6.Gobbs T. Filosofskie osnovanija uchenija o grazhdanstve. – Minsk Harvest 2001.
7.Dzh. Lokk. Izbrannye filosofskie proizvedenija v dvuh tomah. T.2. – M., 1960. O gosudarstvennom prav-lenii. S.5-137.
8.Montesk'e Sh. Izbrannye proizvedenija. O duhe zakonov. – M., 1955.
9.M. Dzhenis, R. Kjej, Je. Brjedli. Evropejskoe pravo v oblasti prav cheloveka (Praktika i kommentarii). – M., 1997.
10.Viner N. Chelovek upravljajushhij. Chelovecheskoe ispol'zovanie chelovecheskih sushhestv. Kibernetika i obshhestvo. – SPb.: Piter, 2001.; Viner N. Tvorec i Budushhee. Ja matematik. – M.: OOO «Izdatel'stvo AST», 2003.; Zhurnal Chto novogo v nauke i tehnike. Razgovor cheloveka s mashinoj, #6, ijun' 2006.
 
 
Legislation perfection issues
Valeev Kh.A.
State civil service in the system of state administration of modern Russia: problems of human resources

The process of democratic rule-of-law state formation in the Russian Federation presupposes the ex-istence of an efficient administrative system. Efficiency of state civil service system is a cornerstone of state’s efficiency. Performance of state power functioning is determined by the organisation of the state machine and the quality of its managing personnel. The state civil service in the Russian Federation is called upon to ensure a stable state management.
Key words: administrative reform, state service, state civil service, state government, staff policy. 
 
 
Legislation perfection issues
Garipov R.F.
Private ownership of land: the experience of agrarian reforms in Russian and the countries of  Eastern Europe

The author examines the Stolypins agrarian reform of the beginning of the XX century and attempts to introduce private ownership of land in Russia. The agrarian reforms on the post-socialist countries of Eastern Europe  and Russia in 1990-s, similar to Stolypins one, lead to a dramatic drop in the agricultural industry. Thus introduction of private property of land alone guarantees neither modernisation nor rise in the efficiency of production.
Key words: stolypin, agrarian reform, land property, privatisation of land, agricultural industry, modernisation, production efficiency.
Work bibliographic list
1.Kara-Murza S. Sovetskaja civilizacija.– T.1.– M., 2002.–S. 68; Davletshin R.A. Agrarnye reformy v Rossii nachala i konca XX v. //Agrarnaja reforma P.A.Stolypina i sovremennost'. Sbornik materialov rossijskoj nauch. konf., posvjashh. 140-letiju so dnja rozh-denija P.A.Stolypina. – Ufa: BGAU, 2002. – S. 47.
2.Davletshin R.A. Ukaz. soch. – S. 46.
3.Kozhinov V. Rossija. Vek XX. – M., 2008. – S. 327.
4.Agropromyshlennyj kompleks Rossii na puti k rynku. – M., 2001. – S. 478.
5.Agrarnaja reforma v stranah Central'no-Vostochnoj Evropy i Rossii. – M., 2003. - S. 9.
6.Glinkina S.P., Orlik I.I. Rossija i Central'no-Vostochnaja Evropa na rubezhe XX – XXI vv. //Novaja i novejshaja istorija. – 2006, #4. – S. 15.
 
 
Legislation perfection issues
Abdrakhmanov A.F.
Legal regulation of the state civil service in the Russian Federation and the Republic of Bashkortostan

The given article presents to the reader normative legal standings initially defining legal regulation of social relations which emerge, change or cease in connection with the realisation of the constitutional rights of the Russian citizen when taking and performing civil service and in the sphere of its realisation and functioning. 
Legal grounds being set by the law serve as fundamental principles on which further legal regulation of the civil service when realised on the federal and  regional levels is based.
The cited normative legal acts are dated May 8th, 2009.
Key words: state service in the Russian Federation, State service system, types of state service, state civil service, federal state civil service. 
 
 
Legislation perfection issues
Gidiyatullina I.N.
Evolution of the notion “revenue” in the illegal enterprise

The deriving of revenue on a large and especially large scale is recognised by the Criminal Code of the RF, Article 171 as a reson fro criminal prosecution. An issue of interpretation of the notion “revenue from the illegal enterprise” emerges. By “the revenue” should be understood earnings before deduction of expenses connected with carrying out of such activities.
Key words: income, entrepreneurship, proceeds, profit.
Work bibliographic list
1.Kotin V. Ugolovnaja otvetstvennost' za nezakonnoe predprinimatel'stvo // Zakonnost'. – 1995. - #7. – S. 20.
2.Ustinova T.D. Otvetstvennost' za nezakonnuju predprinimatel'skuju i bankovskuju dejatel'nost' // Zakonnost'. - 1999. - # 7. – S. 11.
3.Lopashenko N.A. Prestuplenija v sfere jekonomicheskoj dejatel'nosti. Kommentarij k glave 22 UK. – Rostov- na -Donu, 1999. - S.65.
4.Jani P.S. Dohod ot nezakonnogo predprinimatel'stva // Zakonnost'. - 2000. - # 6. - S. 46.
5.Koshaeva T.O. Nezakonnoe predprinimatel'stvo i ugolovnyj zakon // Ugolovnoe pravo. - 1998. - # 3. - S.110.
6.Tolkachev V.V. Nezakonnoe predprinimatel'stvo // Predprinimatel' bez obrazovanija juridicheskogo lica. PBOJuL. – 2005. - # 4. - Sistema GARANT.
 
 
Legislation perfection issues
Bebik N.V.
On the problems of justice of peace apparatus optimisation

The article is devoted to the issue of legal nature of the justice of peace apparatus. The author worked on the definition of the organisation order of justice of peace apparatus’ work, the sequence of selection and appointment of the apparatus personnel, employees’ of the apparatus status, the need of their further training , problems of cooperation between the justices of peace and the personnel of their apparatus. Also the analysis of both federal and regional legislation is carried out, a number of propositions is given.
Key words: lay justice, judicial authority, justice of peace, justice of peace apparatus, court trainee, judge-organiser. 
Work bibliographic list
1.Aleksandrov S.V. Apparat mirovogo sud'i: problemy pravovoj prirody i organizacii raboty // Rossijskaja justicija. 2009. # 5. S. 70-72
2.Kolokolov N.A., Pavlikov S.G., Sachkov A.N. Mirovaja justicija - M., 2008. - S. 226-227
3.Latysheva N.A. Jeticheskie osnovy povedenija specialistov sudebnogo uchastka // Mirovoj sud'ja. - 2006. - # 6. - S. 13-15
4.Kolokolov N.A., Pavlikov S.G., Sachkov A.N. Ukaz. soch. S. 237-238
 
 
Legislation perfection issues
Suyundukova A.Yu.
On the issue of autonomous financial liability of a peasant (farm) enterprise

The article deals with the issues of autonomous financial liability of a peasant (farm) enterprise as a specific subject of law due to which exaction of debt by the creditors must be applied to the property of the farm enterprise, detached from personal property of its members, registered on a separate statement of balance and used for systematic acquisition of income from agricultural activity.
Key words: autonomous financial liability, property of large farm enterprises, personal property of members.
Work bibliographic list
1.Zvereva E.A. Individual'nye predprinimateli: individual'nyj status predprinimatelja-grazhdanina // Pravo i jekonomika. – 1998. – # 6. – S. 20. Ustjukova V.V. Grazhdansko-pravovoe regulirovanie sozdanija i funkcionirovanija krest'janskih (fermerskih) hozjajstv kak sub"ektov predprinimatel'skoj dejatel'nosti // kn: Predprinimatel'skaja dejatel'nost' v sel'skom hozjajstve Rossii. Pravovye voprosy / Otv. red.: Beljaeva Z.S., Ikonickaja I.A. – M.: Institut gosudarstva i prava Rossijskoj akademii nauk, 1998. – S. 32.
2.Vol'dman Ju. Ob osobennostjah pravovogo regulirovanija truda v krest'janskom (fermerskom) hozjajstve // Hozjajstvo i pravo. – 1998. – # 3. – S. 38–41; Makarova O.A. Pravovoe polozhenie krest'janskogo (fermerskogo) hozjajstva // Kodeks-info. – 2000. – # 1. – S. 10.
3.Guseva T.A., Larina N.V. Individual'nyj predprinimatel': ot registracii do prekrashhenija dejatel'nosti. – izdanie tret'e, pererabotannoe i dopolnennoe. – M.: ZAO Justicinform, 2005. – S. 133. Podsosonnaja V.V. Juridicheskoe obosoblenie imushhestva // Podgotovlen dlja sistemy Konsul'tantPljus, 2004. Chashkova S.Ju. Krest'janskoe (fermerskoe) hozjajstvo kak sub"ekt prava i sub"ekt otvetstvennosti: sovremennoe polozhenie i perspektivy // Sibirskij Juridicheskij Vestnik. – 2000. – # 2. //This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..ruJetot e-mail adres zashhishhen ot spam-botov, dlja ego prosmotra u Vas dolzhen byt' vkljuchen Javascript <This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..ruJetot e-mail adres zashhishhen ot spam-botov, dlja ego prosmotra u Vas dolzhen byt' vkljuchen Javascript > (2009. 11dekabrja). Mel'nikov N.N. Identifikacija sub"ekta prava pri rassmotrenii sporov s uchastiem krest'janskih (fermerskih) hozjajstv // Hozjajstvo i pra-vo. – 2008. – # 10. – S. 56–62. Serova O.A. Krest'janskoe (fermerskoe) hozjajstvo v sisteme sub"ektov predprinimatel'skoj dejatel'nosti // Rossijskij sud'ja. – 2006. – # 2. – S. 6–8. Tjutjutnik P. N. Obshhaja dolevaja sobstvennost' v grazhdanskom zakonodatel'stve Rossii: Avtoref. dis. …kand. jurid. nauk. - Rostov-na-Donu, 2006. – S. 10.
4.Podsosonnaja V.V. Juridicheskoe obosoblenie imushhestva // Podgotovlen dlja sistemy Konsul'tant Pljus, 2004.
5.Chashkova S.Ju. Krest'janskoe (fermerskoe) hozjajstvo kak sub"ekt prava i sub"ekt otvetstvennosti: sovremennoe polozhenie i perspektivy // This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..ruJetot e-mail adres zashhishhen ot spam-botov, dlja ego prosmotra u Vas dolzhen byt' vkljuchen Javascript < This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..ruJetot e-mail adres zashhishhen ot spam-botov, dlja ego prosmotra u Vas dolzhen byt' vkljuchen Javascript > (2009. 11dekabrja
 
 
Legislation perfection issues
Meschaninov A.P. 
Methodological approaches to the definition of “management” in the administrative law

The formation of the notions “management” and “governance” is promoted by the elaboration of methodological approaches to the contents of their definitions. The main approaches which reveal the es-sence of their content are the definitions of “management” as an influence or an activity. The most accurate rationale of one of these approaches will lead to the full disclosure of the concept “governance”.
Key words: management, methodological approaches to the definition of the notion “management”, influence, activity. 
Work bibliographic list
1.Atamanchuk G. V. Teorija gosudarstvennogo upravlenija: kurs lekcij / G. V. Atamanchuk. – 4-e izd., ster. – M.: Omega-L, 2006. – S. 44.
2.Ponjatie i soderzhanija upravlenija // <http://de.ifmo.ru/bk_netra/page.php?tutindex=3&index=4 > (2010. 22 aprelja)
3.Atamanchuk G. V. Teorija gosudarstvennogo upravlenija: kurs lekcij. – S. 45.
4.Kazancev N.M. Administrativno-pravovoj status grazhdan i inyh lic v pravootnoshenijah upravlenija // Administrativno-pravovoj status cheloveka i grazhdanina (sed'mye «Lazarevskie chtenija»). - Gosudarstvo i pravo. - 2003. - #11. – S. 18.
5.Tihomirov Ju.A. Vlast' i upravlenie v socialisticheskom obshhestve. – M.: «Juridicheskaja literatura», 1968. – S. 13.
6.Kozlov Ju.M. Predmet sovetskogo administrativnogo prava. - M.: Izdatel'stvo Moskovskogo Gosudarstvennogo Universiteta, 1967. – S.6.
7.Atamanchuk G. V. Teorija gosudarstvennogo upravlenija: kurs lekcij. – S. 50.
8.Babaev S. F. Mehanizm sovershenstvovanija gosudarstvennogo upravlenija (administrativno-pravovoj aspekt). - Riga: Zinatne, 1986. – S. 26.
9.Gizzatullin H. I. Kurs lekcij po administrativnomu pravu. - Ufa: RIC BashGU, 2007. – S. 6.<http://psi.webzone.ru/intro/intro03.htm/Teorija deja-tel'nosti> (2010 g. 26 aprelja); Zub A.T. Strategiche-skij menedzhment: Teorija i praktika: Uchebnoe poso-bie dlja vuzov — M.: Aspekt Press, 2002. — S.6.
10.Judin Je.G. Problema dejatel'nosti v filosofii i nauke // Je.G. Judin. Sistemnyj podhod i princip dejatel'nosti. Metodologicheskie problemy sovremennosti. – M., 1978. – S. 269; Teorija dejatel'nosti / Vikipedija. Svobodnaja jenciklopedija / <http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teorija_dejatel'nosti> (2010. 25 marta).
11.Ljasko V.I. Strategicheskoe planirovanie razvitija predprijatija: Uchebnoe posobie dlja vuzov / V.I. Ljasko – M.: Izdatel'stvo «Jekzamen», 2005. – S. 6.
12.Podelinskaja I.A., Bjankin M.V. Strategicheskoe planirovanie: uchebnoe posobie. – Ulan-Udje: Izd-vo VSGTU, 2005. – S. 4-5.
13.Atamanchuk G. V. Teorija gosudarstvennogo upravlenija: kurs lekcij. – S. 46.
14.Atamanchuk G. V. Teorija gosudarstvennogo upravlenija: kurs lekcij. – S. 46.
15.Dal' V. Tolkovyj slovar' zhivogo velikorusskogo jazyka. T. 1. – M.: Rus. jaz., 1989. – S. 227; Tolkovyj slovar' russkogo jazyka. Tom - 1. M.: OGIZ, 1935. – S. 338.
 

ISSN 2500-0217 / Включен в Перечень ВАК